Get Adobe Flash player
    Weekly End Time Bible Prophecy Updates
    END TIME BIBLE PROPHECY ". The Primary Focus is the Futurist view of Bible Prophecy, the Last Seven Years and the Events leading up to it. Providing Good Links, Study Guides and Biblical Answers.
    We respect your privacy.

    Post Tribulation

    Post-Tribulation Rapture

     

    This doctrine holds that there is a Resurrection-Rapture of living believers in Jesus Christ at the end of the age (or the “End time“). Post-tribulationists believe that Christians will remain on the Earth through the three and a half year great tribulation period. This period starts at the Abomination of Desolation and ends at the Battle of Armageddon. They will be gathered by the angels to meet Christ in the air (raptured) at Christ’s second coming immediately after the great tribulation just before the battle of Armageddon and then return with Him as Christ descends to the Earth, to usher in the Millennium (World to Come) on earth.

     

    Matthew 24:29-31 ASV 29But immediately after the tribulation of those days the sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken: 30and then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. 31And he shall send forth his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other.

     

    1 Thessalonians 4:15-17 ASV 15For this we say unto you by the word of the Lord, that we that are alive, that are left unto the coming of the Lord, shall in no wise precede them that are fallen asleep. 16For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven, with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first; 17then we that are alive, that are left, shall together with them be caught up in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever be with the Lord.

     

    For additional references, see also the parallel passages from Mark 13:24-27 and Luke 21:20-28. While the passages in Luke 21 parallels Matthew and Mark, it offers a couple of interesting clarifications. This passage in Luke offers interesting references to some of the major events which are greatly elaborated on in the Book of Revelation. Reading all three Books of the Bible in parallel, it would appear that Luke elaborates on the “abomination of desolation” describing Jerusalem being surrounded by the armies of the world and of Jerusalem’s imminent destruction (Luke 21:20).

     

    Another account which lends support to the idea of a post-tribulation rapture is in 2 Peter 3:10-13, where the idea of the “Day of the Lord” coming as a “thief in the night” comes from. This idea of imminence, according to the post-tribulation view, only applies to the wicked and the spiritually unprepared people that are still alive before the Return of Christ. Therefore, only God’s elect (Christians) will fully have a clear understanding of the timing of the second coming, and therefore Christ’s coming will not catch the believers by surprise, but only those who are spiritually ignorant regarding the truth.[1][2][3][4][5] In the passage of 2 Peter 3:10-13, Christ’s return is equated with the “elements being melted”, and “the earth also and the works therein shall be burned up”. Opposing views are not non-existent within the realm of Christian Eschatology. Two opposing views, pre-tribulationism and mid-tribulationism, see the rapture and the Second Coming (or Greek, paraousia) of Christ as separate events; while in post-tribulationism the two events are identical or simultaneous.

     

    Another key difference between the pre-, mid-, and post-tribulation lines of theology is the number of times that Jesus Christ must return. Although it is not directly referenced, in both the pre- and mid-tribulation raptures, Christ must then return a third time, at the end of the Tribulation period.

     

    The belief is that God’s Elect from all ages will be translated from mortal bodies into immortal glorified bodies at the Second Coming of Christ and that this will be at the end of the age. This event, it is believed, will come at the conclusion of what is termed the 70th Week of Daniel, the final seven years of this present age. This view was held by the early Church Fathers and has been held by Christians since that time. The doctrine of the Post-Tribulation Rapture is today held by a growing number of evangelical Christians. For Post-Tribulationists concerned about the recent decline of Christian faith, doctrine, and morals in the western church, an important reason to advance the Post-Tribulation Rapture doctrine relates to the importance of preparation of believers for “witness under trial”.

     

    The “witness under trial” issue was of major concern to evangelist Corrie Ten Boom, whose family suffered in Nazi prison camps during World War II for the crime of protecting Jews. Corrie Ten Boom preached that the Pre-Tribulation Rapture would leave the Christian church ill-prepared for witness under persecution, just as it had in China when Mao Zedong rose to power, and warned that Pre-Tribulationism was the sort of false doctrine that Jesus warned about.

     

    Another idea is that following the Great Tribulation, the False Prophet, or “The Beast out of the Earth” and the Antichrist or “The Beast out of the Sea” will be condemned upon Jesus Christ’s return, and all those who endured or died for Christ‘s return will be raptured to heaven and, following the Millennium, Satan will be condemned and the remaining dead believers will be raised and raptured into the new heaven.

     

    Post-tribulationists broadly base their doctrine on the complementary concepts that a two phase pre-Tribulation rapture is never mentioned explicitly in the Bible,[6] and that the “whole counsel of Scripture”[7] seems to clearly teach that the resurrection and rapture of the Church will be the result of the visible, physical Second Coming of Jesus Christ to Earth and that Christians are to look and watch for that event.[8]

     

    Matthew 24:29-31 and 1 Thessalonians 4:15-17 both mention the same actors (Jesus, his angels) and the same events (Jesus coming, the trumpet of God, and the gathering of the elect) in the same order. The latter passage written by the Apostle Paul is seen as being based on the former because of the usage of “by the word of the Lord” in verse 15[9] and that they are talking about the same event, but the first passage is explicitly dated “after the Tribulation”, and the second is where we get the term Rapture.[10]

     

    Contrasting opinion maintains that the passages are not talking about the same event despite some similarities because of details that are absent between the two passages and that the rapture event was a “mystery” until it was revealed in First Corinthians which the Thessalonian recipients would have been unaware of.[11]

     

    Post-Tribulationists respond to the opposing views of Pre-Tribulationists in a variety of ways:

     

    Some Post-tribulationalists see the Rapture and the Second Coming of Christ as part of one main event.[12][13] Support for this claim is found in 2 Thessalonians 2:1-3 in part because of the way the Apostle Paul introduces his topic, “Now concerning the coming of our Lord and our gathering together with him.” This was an ancient way of introducing your topic of discussion and later Paul refers back to the two nouns at least twice as “the Day of the Lord” or “that day.” Thus, “the coming” and “gathering” seem to be two ways of referring to one event, “the day of the Lord.”[14]

     

    It seems impractical for Paul to go to great lengths describing the coming of the Antichrist (and the falling away) to the Thessalonians[15] in order to calm them down that the day of Christ’s reign on earth had not happened yet if they were not going to be there for it as maintained by the pre-tribulational position. He would be more comforting by reminding them that they wouldn’t be present for it[16] than to precisely detail his recognition and say “Don’t let anyone deceive you in any way, for that day will not come until the rebellion occurs and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the man doomed to destruction”.[17]

     

    The most common passage used in defending a pre-tribulational position is 1 Thessalonians 4. This passage alone does not mention where the gathered ones finally end up but that those who are alive will be caught up to meet Christ in the air and always be with the Lord.[18] Rather it mentions the dead rising, Christ’s coming, angels, the trumpet of God along with the gathering of the elect and all of these participants are present in Matthew 24:30-31 31, which is clearly a Second Coming passage even agreed to by pre-tribulationalists. The author, the Apostle Paul says the Rapture will occur “at the last trumpet”.[19] To be consistent with Revelation 11 this trumpet call must occur after the Tribulation. In the same way, Revelation 21 mentions the first resurrection after the Second Coming in Revelation 19. By definition, there can be no trumpet call after the last one, and no resurrection before the first.

     

    Linguistic support for a one-event 2nd Coming are in the words “meet” and “coming” in 1 Thessalonians 4. The meet in 1 Thessalonians 4:17 and in Matthew 25:1 (a Second Coming parable) refers to the custom of people going out to meet a dignitary as he was approaching their city before he got there, and accompanying or welcoming him back to where they came from.[9] This is also the usage in Acts 28:15 of those going out to meet Paul as he headed toward them in Rome. Also, the Greek term parousia[20] has the idea of a grand dignitary making his arrival to a certain location. The rest of the passage supports this grand arrival with His coming being heralded with trumpet, angels, and a surging ‘city’ of gathered believers going out to meet Him. Who more grand than the Lord Jesus Christ at His coming to reign on earth? This passage lends more weight to the post-tribulational position.[16]

     

    Another strength for this position is Paul saying when the church would receive rest for its suffering.[21] It would take place at the revealing of Jesus Christ with fire and judgment and at this time those who were afflicting the church at Thessalonica would be repaid for such treatment. No mention is made of a Pre-tribulational removal but that rest comes at His Coming and so does judgment.[22]

     

    A passage much debated regarding the timing of the Rapture is Revelation 3:10, which speaks of the Philadelphian church being “kept from the hour of trial which is about to come upon the whole earth to test those who dwell on the earth.”[23] The debate centers around the phrase “kept from” which could be taken to mean “physical removal from” (Pre-trib) or “preservation from or in the midst of” (Post-trib).[24] However it is interesting to note that the verse denotes that the testing is for “those who dwell on the earth.” This is a common phrase referring to unbelievers.[25] What we see later in Revelation, on at least 3 occasions, is that the saints are “sealed” and kept out of harm’s way when God pours out specific judgments which only affect His unbelieving enemies.[25][26][27]

     

    Linguistic highlight the idea that Christians are preserved by God through tribulation rather than removed:

     

    I pray not that thou shouldest take them out of the world, but that thou shouldest keep them from the evil.[28]

     

    This passage is one of the most blunt verses, showing that Jesus himself did not want the Christians taken out of the world in order to protect them from evil but had the intention of preservation in the midst of it. This is a place where pre-tribulationism lacks linguistic favor because this verse and Revelation 3:10 are the only places where the exact phrase tereo ek translated from Greek into keep from are found and that by the same author, the disciple John.[29]

     

    The pretribulational argument that there are ‘two phases’ to Christ’s coming (a Rapture and a later Second Advent)[30] runs into difficulties with Acts 1:11, which nearly equates Christ’s Ascension to heaven with his Second Coming. Logically, the Second Coming cannot have two phases if the Ascension only had one. This eliminates two phases of His Coming with a 7 year interval. Likewise, heaven must “receive” or contain Jesus “until the period of restoration of all things about which God spoke by the mouth of His holy prophets from ancient time”.[31] Most scholars[32] see this “restoration of all things” as the one-thousand year reign of Christ on earth (as prophesied in the Old Testament) which begins just after the Second Advent. If Christ is to remain in heaven until this coming rule of His according to thess verses (see also Hebrews 9:27,28), it would seem the next main prophetic event would be the Second Coming[33] rather than Him coming 7 years prior to get the church, bring them back to heaven, and then leaving heaven for earth again as the pre-tribulational rapture position indicates.[34]

     

    Pre-tribulational usage of Luke 17 can also be counter-balanced. In this eschatological scenario, Luke 17:37 explains what happens to the people that are “taken”: the eagles gather together at their [dead] bodies. Do they eat them? “Taken” may also have the idea of judgment and that Luke 17:22-37 is referring to the unmistakable visual nature of the Second Coming. Even the disciples are warned not to believe reports that Christ has come if they have not seen it “for just as the lightning, when it flashes out of one part of the sky, shines to the other part of the sky, so will the Son of Man be in His day.[35] Many take the fact that vultures hovering over a dead body is clearly visible from a great distance away to mean that the Second Coming will be clearly visible and will not be hidden. It seems that Luke 17 can be compared to Revelation 19, which reads that the fowls are invited to a feast—on the flesh of men, small and great, at the Lord’s coming.

     

    The Parable in Matthew 13 explains that the unsaved (tares) are destroyed first before the saved (wheat) are addressed. This parable[36] describes what the kingdom of heaven is like and it uses agricultural metaphor to explain that believers and unbelievers will remain together until the harvest. When is the harvest? Well, when Jesus explains the parable.[37] He says the harvest is the “end of the age” in verse 39. At that time he sends his angels[38] to destroy the tares while the wheat (believers) remain and shine forth as the sun in His Father’s kingdom. This seems to fit better with the Rapture and the Second Coming being one event rather than a time gap of 7 years.

     

    Zechariah 14, speaks of the “Day of the Lord” and that “in that Day His feet will stand on the Mount of Olives.” This exactly parallels the angel’s statement in Acts 1, “that as He left so shall He return.” Tying this with I Thessalonians 4:16-17, we see all the living and dead Christians are gathered to Jesus at that time. Going back to Zechariah 14:5 we read, “Then the LORD my God will come, and all the holy ones with him. ” This inexorably links the return of Jesus to the glorification and “rapture” of Christians to Him.

     

    In Revelation 2:25 31 Jesus says to the faithful at Thyatira, “Nevertheless what you have, hold fast until I come.” In other words, ‘hold onto the truth of the Christian faith and its obedience amidst the false teaching of Jezebel and her sins, until My coming again.’ Pre-trib commentators agree this could be talking about the Second Coming of Christ (John MacArthur,[39] Robert L. Thomas).[40] Would Jesus say hold on to the faith until I come again if they were not going to be there when he returned, but would have already been raptured? Expositor’s Bible Commentary also makes this assertion.[41]

     

    Be patient, therefore, brethren, until the coming of the Lord. Behold the farmer waits for the precious produce of the soil, being patient about it, until it gets the early and late rains. You too be patient; strengthen your hearts, for the coming of the Lord is at hand.[42]

     

    They are to be patient amidst persecution until when? Until the coming (parousia) of the Lord. Parousia is well known to mean “presence” and refers to His second coming many times in the New Testament.[43] Also notice that the farming analogy seems to indicate that the farmer is aware of the coming rains just as the believer is aware of coming end time events.[44] For example Jesus warned “when you see these things begin to take place [end time signs in the sun, moon, and stars / world chaos], straighten up and lift up your heads, because your redemption is drawing near.”[45] This manner of expectancy is objected to on the grounds that it destroys the idea of Christ’s rapture of the church being imminent, or able to occur at any moment. But imminent probably doesn’t mean ‘at any moment’ in the New Testament.[46] Many New Testament passages implicitly rule out an “any second” imminency (Matthew 24:45-51…25:5,19;Luke 19:11-27;John 21:18-19…Acts 9:15…).

     

    [47] At the very least Apostles Peter and Paul could not have believed in this kind of imminency because Peter was told by Jesus what manner of death he was to die and that it would take place many years later. Jesus said, “Truly, truly, I say to you, when you were younger, you used to gird yourself, and walk wherever you wished; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands [be crucified], and someone else will gird you, and bring you where you do not wish to go.”[48] Could Peter think the Rapture was at any moment with this enduring prediction by Jesus?[49] Also, it was told of Paul that he would bear Christ’s name “before the Gentiles and kings and the sons of Israel” and that God would “show him how much he is to suffer for My name’s sake.”[50] Does an any moment Rapture fit with such a massive missionary plan revealed by God for Paul’s life which took decades to complete? Jesus encouraged the first disciples and all Christians, to look for certain events which would indicate His coming was “at the doors.” This coupled with other passages like 1 Thessalonians 5:2-6, seems to indicate moral watchfulness, waiting in expectancy,[51] and sobriety (“be sober”) and that the wrath of that day will overtake those in darkness (unbelievers) like a thief “but you, brethren, are not in darkness, that the day should overtake you like a thief.”[52][53] Thus a different concept of imminency emerges.

     

    Jesus, speaking chronologically in the Olivet Discourse regarding end time events,[54] goes from the escalation of troubling times beginning in the 1st century and the present age (highlighting the destruction of Jerusalem by Rome in A.D. 70) to the time of tribulation and then to His Second Coming without any mention of a prior removal of the church 7 or 3.5 years before it. One author sees Jesus as advocating a “delay” between the destruction of Jerusalem and His Second Advent.[55] On the contrary, he states that “immediately after the tribulation of those days…they [the world] shall see the son of Man coming…and He shall send His angels, and they shall gather His elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other.”[56] Therefore, Jesus seems to put the rapture just before his second coming or on his way to earth. The phrase “gathering together” describes the rapture in 2 Thessalonians 2:1 using the noun form of the same Greek word.[57]

     

    Paul says: “we who are alive and remain [on the earth] until the coming of the Lord, shall not precede those who have fallen asleep[died].”[58] Then he points out that the Lord’s coming with angels and the trumpet call will invite those already dead in Christ to rise from the dead before the ones on earth participate in the event. Then Paul states: “Then we who are alive and remain [on earth] shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and thus we shall always be with the Lord.”[59] Some commentators[60] note that because Paul used the plural “we” when referring to those who “are alive and remain[on earth]” indicates that Paul believed that he and all believers on earth might witness and be a part of the Second Coming of Christ from earth.

     

    This would indicate that he would be on earth just prior to the coming of the Lord and the Rapture. This is also the usage when he speaks of the same event saying: “We shall not all sleep [die], but we shall all be changed-in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.”[61] This passage adds the fact that believers will receive glorified bodies which is missing from the Thessalonian passage].”[62] If believers were raptured before the tribulation then why would Paul use “we” and consider himself with all Christians to possibly be those who would be “alive and remaining [on earth] until the coming of the Lord?” They wouldn’t be alive and remaining on the earth at His coming in a pre-tribulational scenario but would already be with Jesus in clouds along with the other believers who had died in Christ.

     

     

     

     

    This is probably God’s clearest explanation of the End Time Events that has ever been written. We get Familiar with this passage because we have heard it so often. Please put your Mind in Neutral and just read this with an Open Mind because Everything Jesus said here is going to happen. Earthquakes and weather changes are happening, the fear of War is Everywhere……” and there shall be famines, and pestilences” which will probably start happening in the form of Plagues etc. Jesus is our protection. Psalm 91 and many others. He Will Keep us or take us Home during these Trying Times Ahead.

    3 And as he sat upon the mount of Olives, the disciples came unto him privately, saying, Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world?

    4 And Jesus answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man deceive you. 5 For many shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many. 6 And ye shall hear of wars and rumours of wars: see that ye be not troubled: for all these things must come to pass, but the end is not yet. 7 For nation shall rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom: and there shall be famines, and pestilences, and earthquakes, in divers places. 8 All these are the beginning of sorrows.
    9 Then shall they deliver you up to be afflicted, and shall kill you: and ye shall be hated of all nations for my name’s sake. 10 And then shall many be offended, and shall betray one another, and shall hate one another. 11 And many false prophets shall rise, and shall deceive many. 12 And because iniquity shall abound, the love of many shall wax cold. 13 But he that shall endure unto the end, the same shall be saved.

    14 And this gospel of the kingdom shall be preached in all the world for a witness unto all nations; and then shall the end come. 15 When ye therefore shall see the abomination of desolation, spoken of by Daniel the prophet, stand in the holy place, (whoso readeth, let him understand:) 16 Then let them which be in Judaea flee into the mountains: 17 Let him which is on the housetop not come down to take any thing out of his house: 18 Neither let him which is in the field return back to take his clothes. 19 And woe unto them that are with child, and to them that give suck in those days! 20 But pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the sabbath day: 21 For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever shall be. 22 And except those days should be shortened, there should no flesh be saved: but for the elect’s sake those days shall be shortened.

    23 Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not. 24 For there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, and shall shew great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect. 25 Behold, I have told you before. 26 Wherefore if they shall say unto you, Behold, he is in the desert; go not forth: behold, he is in the secret chambers; believe it not.

    27 For as the lightning cometh out of the east, and shineth even unto the west; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be. 28 For wheresoever the carcase is, there will the eagles be gathered together. 29 Immediately after the tribulation of those days shall the sun be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken: 30 And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. 31 And he shall send his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other. Matt 24:3-31 (KJV) Sorry so long….

     

    REVELATION NOTES

    THE SOURCE AND SETTING OF THE MESSAGE (1:1-20)

    Overview: Revelation 1 sets the context for the book. The prologue (1:1-3) shows that Revelation came from God through Christ, an angel, and John. It also presents the purpose of the book: blessing from hearing and heeding the book’s message. Throughout the book the hidden message of God is centered on the contents of a scroll with seven seals (5:5, 7; 6:1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 12; 8:1). It is the vision of Christ in 1:9-20 and the contents of the scroll that contain the revelation. The vision of Christ for the churches shows that he is at present the awesome and potentially lethal God who will in the future come to judge the world.

    Prologue (1:1-3)

    The prologue was composed by John after he experienced the visions recorded in the book. He used this prologue to introduce his readers to what the book was about and how they were to respond to it. The book is first of all a revelation concerning Jesus Christ. “Revelation” means “disclosure” or “unveiling.” Jesus is both the source and the subject of the revelation. The message is for his “servants.” The book begins and ends by stressing Christ’s return for his servants (1:1, 3; 22:3, 6-7, 10, 12, 20). For the concept of “soon” (or “quickly”), see Luke 18:8 and Romans 16:20. Also, consider 2 Peter 3:8-13. This is a letter to slaves encouraging them to obey their Master’s commands in light of his expected return.

    The message was presented largely in signs and symbols. Signs and symbols teach truth by transference. What is known about the sign in a known realm reveals something about the unknown realm toward which the sign points. Most of the symbols or signs in Revelation are explained in the context or in some other place in Scripture. A blessing is promised for those who read and heed the words of the prophecy.

    What is there to “obey” (1:3) in the book of Revelation? Revelation 1:3 is a beatitude promising blessing for those who heed what is in the book. Revelation reveals other blessings in 14:13; 16:15; 19:9; 20:6; 22:7, 14 (cf. Luke 11:28). These blessings form a stark contrast with the curses at the end of the book (22:18-19). The essence of taking the message of the book into one’s life is maintaining love for Christ and one’s family. This will result in overcoming, or “victory” (cf. 2:7, 11, 17, 26; 3:5, 12, 21; 5:5; 11:7; 13:7; 17:14; 21:7; Matt. 24:13). For seeing the letter as “prophecy” (1:3), see 22:7, 10, 18-19.

    Greeting (1:4-8)

    As with the prologue in 1:1-3, the greeting was written after John had experienced the visions of the book. It presents the major themes of the book: seven churches, the eternality of God, Jesus the faithful witness, and God’s eternal glory and dominion. These themes will be illustrated throughout the book. John gave a standard blessing: “grace and peace.” Revelation is addressed to the seven churches of Asia. The churches were in cities Paul had visited on his second and third missionary journeys. As elder, or bishop, of Ephesus, the apostle John was responsible for these churches. Note the structure of 1:4-8. It starts and ends with the eternality of God (cf. Exod. 3:14-15). The middle part describes the person and work of Jesus, which results in believers being “priests” (1:6). The servants of God do their priestly ministry in Christ surrounded by the eternal power and nature of the Father.

    The “sevenfold Spirit” (1:4) is variously interpreted as referring to: (1) the seven angels (1:16, 20); (2) the fullness of the Holy Spirit in all his ministries (2:7, 11, 17, 29; cf. Isa. 11:2-5; 1 Cor. 12:4, 13); or (3) a heavenly entourage of spirits that have a special ministry in connection with the Lamb. It is always best to see if the book itself can shed light on an issue. In this case 3:1; 4:5; and 5:6 refer to the seven spirits. These verses show that the main emphasis is on the power and presence (“horns and eyes,” 5:6) of God on the earth (cf. Zech. 4:2, 10). The number “seven” appears fifty-four times in Revelation. Throughout the Bible the number seven is associated with the idea of completion and perfection (cf. Gen. 2:2; Exod. 20:10).

    Jesus Christ is described as “the faithful witness” (1:5; cf. 2:13; 11:3; 17:6) in order to encourage the same from the readers. This relates to the bookwide theme of “overcoming,” or being “victorious” (2:7, 11, 17, 26; 3:5, 12, 21; 5:5; 11:7; 13:7; 17:14; 21:7; cf. Matt. 24:13), enduring to the end faithfully. The “first to rise from the dead” (1:5) refers to Christ (cf. Col. 1:15). He was the first to receive an immortal, resurrection body (cf. 1 Cor. 15:20). As such, he is able to resurrect those who die for their faith (cf. 20:6). The term “kingdom” (1:6) reflects the present unity of believers under their King (“the glory and dominion”). The term “priests” (1:6) reflects the service to God by believers (cf. 5:10; Exod. 19:5-6; Isa. 61:6; 1 Pet. 2:5, 9). This service will continue throughout eternity (cf. 22:3).

    Revelation 1:7 breaks the flow of the narrative. It is an outburst that clearly presents the theme of the book. Daniel 7:13 and Zechariah 12:10 are combined. Their predictions will be fulfilled at Christ’s return (cf. also Matt. 16:27; 24:30; and John 19:37). Note the two “amens” (1:6-7). This glorious picture was needed by those who looked forward to a future filled with uncertainty and tribulation.

    God confirmed his eternal sovereignty in 1:8. For Alpha and Omega, see 21:6; 22:13; and Isaiah 41:4. While some take “the Alpha and the Omega” (1:8) to refer to Christ (21:6), in this context it refers to God who is verifying the contents of the prophecy. He is the “A” to “Z,” that is, the complete God. “Almighty” is used only ten times in the New Testament and nine of its appearances are in this book (1:8; 4:8; 11:17; 15:3; 16:7, 14; 19:6, 15; 21:22; cf. 2 Cor. 6:18). Triumph in tribulation is based on trusting in God to be the most powerful of all.

    Prophetic Commissioning (1:9-20)

    THE FIRST COMMAND TO WRITE (1:9-11)

    The first Roman persecution of Christians was under Nero in a.d. 64-67. He ordered the burning and mutilation of Christians and brought about the deaths of Peter and Paul. The second persecution was under Domitian, around a.d. 95. This persecution brought John to Patmos. At the time of writing Revelation, John was in exile on the island of Patmos, a six by ten mile island in the Aegean Sea about thirty-five miles southwest of Miletus. This island served as a place of banishment during Roman times.

    Revelation 1:9 recounts the major themes of the book: suffering, the kingdom, and patient endurance in Jesus (cf. 3:10; 2 Thess. 3:5). The “Lord’s Day” (1:10) may refer to Sunday, the first day of the week (cf. Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2). If this was the case, John had his vision on the day the seven churches he would address were meeting to worship. It is also possible that the “Lord’s Day” may not refer to Sunday but to the kind of day (that is, a day totally given over to the Lord’s words and acts) on which John received this revelation. For the phrase “in the Spirit” (1:10), see Acts 10:10; 11:5; 22:17; and 2 Corinthians 12:2-4. The loud voice was like a trumpet (1:10; cf. Exod. 19:16, 19; cf. Heb. 12:19; Matt. 24:31; 1 Cor. 15:52; 1 Thess. 4:16). The book was originally written as a prophetic exhortation to seven churches (1:11).

    DESCRIPTION OF THE SPEAKER (1:12-16)

    John’s vision was of the majestic person of Christ, the risen and glorified Lord, standing among the churches. The vision is similar to that recorded in Daniel 7:9-14. But this picture of the risen Lord is radically different from the picture presented in the Gospels, where the risen Lord was mistaken for a gardener and made breakfast for his disciples by the Sea of Galilee. In Revelation the risen Lord is revealed as the fearsome Judge, first of the churches and then of the world. The Lord is presented in this startling way in order to motivate the readers to pay attention. The “seven gold lampstands” (1:12) are identified in 1:20 as the seven churches. The picture of seven lamps occurs in Exodus 25:37; 37:23; and Zechariah 4:2. The “seven stars” (1:16) are identified in 1:20 as seven “angels.”

    There are a variety of opinions regarding the identity of the seven “angels.” Some have understood John to be referring to the human leader or pastor of each local church. Others have viewed them as guardian angels of the churches (1 Cor. 11:10). And others believe the term “angel” should be understood literally as “messenger,” referring to the human messengers sent by the churches to visit John and receive Christ’s letter to their churches (cf. 2:1; for other human messengers in Scripture see Hag. 1:13; Mal. 2:7; Matt. 11:10; Luke 9:52; James 2:25). The order in which the churches are addressed is strictly according to geographical arrangement.

    THE SECOND COMMAND TO WRITE (1:17-20)

    John revealed his personal response to what he saw (1:17), and by doing this, called believers to share his feelings of awe at the vision of Christ among the churches. Jesus comforts John with his right hand (1:17). His charge of the “keys” (1:18) reveals his full power over death. The risen Lord exhibits his full authority to command (1:19; cf. Dan. 8:18; 10:10, 12). The commission in Revelation 1:19 is often seen as the key to understanding the structure of the entire book: “what you have seen” (referring to Rev. 1), “the things that are now happening” (referring to Rev. 2-3), and “the things that will happen later” (referring to Rev. 4-22). John was being instructed to write down the entirety of what he saw and to leave nothing out.

    PRESENT EXHORTATIONS TO THE CHURCHES (2:1-3:22)

    Overview: Each message follows a standard format: (1) the charge to write to the angel of the church; (2) identification of Christ in terms of his appearance in Revelation 1; (3) the church’s positive qualities; (4) words of exhortation; (5) a closing with an exhortation to hear and a promise to the “victorious.” The closing to each message broadens the scope to all the churches. All seven messages are to all churches in every age. The impact of this format for the overall message and purpose of the book is that there is a critical need for Christians to endure a future period of terrible persecution. The churches are told to be “victorious” by returning to their original commitment and guarding against cultural conformity.

    Each of the churches’ letters begins with a vision or characterization of Christ similar to the vision of 1:9-20. The selection of each reference to the vision of Christ matches the special needs of each of the seven churches. See the accompanying chart on the seven churches.

    Each message was intended to deal with the specific internal conditions of each individual church. The churches were commended for their good traits and condemned for their failings.

    Ephesus (2:1-7)

    Ephesus, the foremost city of Asia Minor, was located near the Aegean Sea on the Cayster River and had a population of around 250,000 (see introductory map). The city was the guardian of the temple of Artemis (Diana) and of her image. According to legend, the image fell from heaven (Acts 19:35). The emperor cult flourished at Ephesus, and temples were built there to Claudius, Hadrian, and Severus. The magic arts and mystery cults also flourished there (Acts 19:13-19). Ephesus had a fine harbor, which served as an export center at the west end of the Asiatic caravan route. The city had a fine theater that seated 25,000 people. The church at Ephesus was founded by Aquila, Priscilla, and Paul (Acts 18:18-19). By the time of John’s Revelation, the church had persevered through the trouble of false teachers but had lost its first love.

    VISION OF CHRIST: HOLDS AND WALKS (2:1)

    The vision of Christ holding and walking (2:1) reinforces his intimate knowledge of their hearts and actions. The picture of Christ with a letter to each church relates to his intimate knowledge of the problems each church faces (cf. 1:12, 16; 2:4).

    PRAISE (2:2-3)

    The Lord praised the Ephesian Christians for their deeds, perseverance, and endurance. Toil and patience characterized their overall lifestyle. They were doctrinally sound and had exposed false teachers (cf. Matt. 7:15; Acts 20:29). They had persevered and endured many trials and hardships.

    PROBLEM (2:4-5)

    Although endurance is a key theme throughout the book, it is not the only or final criterion for pleasing Christ. The Lord told these believers that they had left their first love and exhorted them to repent. See Matthew 24:12 for Jesus’ warning that the “love of many will grow cold.” The idea of “love . . . as you did at first” (2:4) is purposely left general to let the readers specify what their own first love for God was (cf. Jer. 2:2; John 13:35; 2 John 1:5). The remedy is to “look,” “turn,” and “work” (2:5). Doctrinal purity and endurance did not guarantee vital inner love for God. The remembrance by believers of their first state of love for Christ is potent for bringing about repentance and action. Christ’s coming to judge (2:5) would be realized by his extinguishing the life of that particular church. There is a close relationship between Christ’s coming to judge the churches (Rev. 2-3) and his coming to judge the world in the day of the Lord (Rev. 4-22).

    EXHORTATION (2:6-7)

    According to the early church fathers, the Nicolaitans were the followers of Nicolas (cf. Acts 6:5). Others understand the name etymologically to refer to those who “conquer the people,” that is, those who usurped authority and dominated the people. In context, their problem is linked to the teaching of Balaam (2:14-15) and may also be related to the works of 2:20-21 concerning food and idols. This also relates to the Jerusalem council’s decrees in Acts 15:29. These exhortations to the churches of Asia Minor (2:7, 11, 17, 29; 3:6, 13, 22) are applicable to all churches and to individual believers as well (cf. Matt. 11:5). “Victorious” (2:7) is a combination of doctrinal purity, faithful witness, and vital love for Christ. Those who are “victorious” are not a special group of Christians but true believers who persevere faithfully to the end (21:7; 2:7, 11, 17, 26; 3:5, 12, 21; cf. 1 John 5:4-5). For the “tree of life,” see Revelation 22:2 and Genesis 2:9; 3:22-24. “Paradise” signifies the place of Edenic fellowship with God.

    THE SEVEN CHURCHES OF ASIA

    Ephesus (2:1)See 1:12, 16.

    Smyrna (2:8)See 1:17-18.

    Pergamum (2:12)See 1:16.

    Thyatira(2:18)See 1:14-15.

    Sardis (3:1)See 1:16.

    Philadelphia (3:7)See 1:18.

    Laodicea (3:14)See 1:5.

     

    Smyrna (2:8-11)

    Smyrna (modern Ismir) is located about thirty-five miles north of Ephesus (see introductory map). It was an important port city and trade center that also boasted of schools of science and medicine. Smyrna was also a center for the imperial cult of emperor worship. Temples at Smyrna were dedicated to the emperor Tiberius, Zeus, and Cybele. The gospel probably reached Smyrna at an early date, presumably from Ephesus (Acts 19:10). The church at Smyrna suffered from poverty and persecution by the Jews. Polycarp, one of the apostle John’s disciples, served as bishop of Smyrna and was martyred there around a.d. 156 when he refused to recant his faith. He was burned alive on a wooden pyre.

    VISION OF CHRIST (2:8)

    The vision of Christ’s experience of suffering (2:8) matches the suffering and death that would be faced by the church in Smyrna (2:10; cf. the picture of Christ in 1:17-18).

    PRAISE (2:9)

    The church at Smyrna experienced great affliction and poverty. Christ’s words, “I know” (2:9), reveal the heart of the Christians’ comfort. It is far from trite to say that God knows about the needs of his people. The spiritual riches of the believers in Smyrna contrasted with their material poverty. This stands in contrast with the state of the believers in the Laodicean church (3:17). For the concept of real versus false Jews, see Romans 2:28-29 and John 8:31-47. The “synagogue of Satan” referred to those who were Jews by birth but did not share Abraham’s faith (cf. Rom. 2:28-29).

    EXHORTATION (2:10-11)

    The “ten days” (2:10) refers to a brief period of suffering (Gen. 24:55; Neh. 5:18; Jer. 42:7; Acts 25:6). Satan was behind the suffering and tribulations of the saints throughout the book. Satan’s work serves as a testing (2:10) for the saints (cf. 3:10). Faithfulness results in getting the crown of life, but only after death. The “second death” (2:11) is described in 20:6, 14 and 21:8. The “second death” refers to eternal separation from God in the lake of fire.

    THE SEVEN CHURCHES: REAL OR SYMBOLIC?

    Some have viewed these churches as picturing seven successive periods of church history. But this view involves considerable speculation and subjectivity. As with any of the letters in the New Testament addressed to particular churches, the churches in Revelation should be understood as real first-century churches, but modern interpreters must also realize that the message is to all of Christ’s churches throughout time. To defend the timelessness of the message is not to withold the original historical reality of the seven churches. The churches are like those addressed in Romans, Ephesians, Philippians, and so forth.

    In addition, emphasis needs to be placed on the prophetic nature of the messages to the churches in Revelation. They are more like oracles than letters, and the command to write (repeated in 2:1, 8, 12, 18; 3:1, 7, 14) is used in the Greek Old Testament to announce prophetic messages. Thus, the letters are prophetic messages written to real churches with timeless messages to Christ’s church throughout the centuries.Pergamum (2:12-17)

    Pergamum was located about fifty miles north of Smyrna and about fifteen miles from the sea (see introductory map). To reach the city from the coast, one could travel up the Caicus River, which was navigable by small craft. Pergamum had a fine library and was the place where parchment was first used. The city was chiefly noted as the religious center of the province of Asia. It was the center of four of the great pagan cults honoring Zeus, Athena, Dionysus, and Asderius. Each of these deities had a beautiful temple. The first temple dedicated to the imperial cult (in honor of Augustus) was built at Pergamum in 29 B.C. The pagan temples and idolatry undoubtedly led John to refer to the city as the place “where that great throne of Satan is located” (2:13).

    VISION OF CHRIST (2:12)

    The Lord is pictured as having a two-edged sword (cf. 1:16). This sword is seen in terrible use later (19:15, 21; cf. also Isa. 49:2; Heb. 4:12). The sword is related to the Lord’s impending visit to the church (2:16).

    PRAISE (2:13)

    The Lord praised the believers in Pergamum for having kept the faith. Antipas (2:13) is described as being a “faithful witness,” an attribute he shared with Christ (1:5). Satan’s work and throne are seen throughout Revelation 2 (2:9, 10, 13, 24; and also 3:9) and are connected to the Old Testament characters of Balaam (2:14) and Jezebel (2:20). Satan’s work to destroy the church will extend into his terrible deeds recorded in Revelation 4-20.

    PROBLEM (2:14-16)

    The Lord pointed out to them that they had allowed immoral teachings to come into their lives. The teachings were not a body of doctrine but a manner of behavior as described by the last part of 2:14. Their problem had two aspects: (1) They were eating food before idols in the temples; and (2) they were engaged in sexual immorality as pagan worship. For Balaam leading the Israelites into immoral activity, see Numbers 25:1-5 in connection with Numbers 31:16. They were involved in worship of false gods, which involved immoral sexual practices. Revelation 2:15 links the above sin to the teachings of the Nicolaitans and sheds light on the teachings of this basically unknown group. The center of their problem was that they were conforming to the ungodly activities of the surrounding society. “Come” (2:16) refers to Christ’s second coming (cf. 3:11; 22:7, 12, 20).

     

    EXHORTATION (2:17)

    The “victorious” person is promised three things. The “manna that has been hidden” probably refers to the sufficiency of the person of Christ, the bread of life (cf. John 6:31-35). The theme of manna has its roots in the Old Testament. It is also seen in John 6 where Jesus indicated that he was the bread of life. The “hidden” concept may refer to the manna that was placed in the Ark for a memorial (Exod. 16:32-34; cf. Heb. 9:4). Tradition says that it was taken by Jeremiah at the time of captivity and hidden in the ground at Mount Nebo (2 Macc. 2:4-7). It was to remain there until the coming of the Messiah when the Ark would be brought to the new temple. Or it might refer to the “food of angels” (Ps. 78:25) that would descend from heaven during the Millennium to feed the blessed (2 Baruch 29:8; Sibylline Oracles, 7.149). A “white stone” was used in antiquity for voting and signified acquittal or acceptance. A white stone also was used as an admission ticket to a banquet, in this case the Messianic banquet. According to the rabbis, precious stones fell from heaven with manna. Christ received a “new name” after his resurrection (cf. Phil. 2:8-11), and believers will also. The essential contrast in this verse is between God’s “hidden manna” and the unclean food and immorality offered by the false teachers at Pergamum.

    Thyatira (2:18-29)

    This longest letter to the churches is addressed to the least known church. Thyatira was an important manufacturing center located approximately forty miles southeast of Pergamum (see introductory map). The city was situated in a valley on the road from Pergamum to Laodicea. Thyatira was especially noted for its trade guilds, which were more organized than in any other ancient city. Their meetings were bound up with acts of pagan worship and immorality. Dye manufacturing was an important industry in Thyatira. The purple dye was made from a root instead of from shellfish. Garment weaving, pottery making, and brass working were also trades known to have existed in Thyatira. In its early days, Thyatira had a temple dedicated to Tyrimnos, an ancient sun god. The gospel may have been brought to the city by Lydia of Thyatira who was converted under Paul’s ministry in Philippi (Acts 16:14). The city is commended in Revelation for its deeds, love, faith, service, and perseverance, but it is rebuked for tolerating the false prophetess “Jezebel” (2:20).

    VISION OF CHRIST (2:18)

    The eyes and feet of the Lord are stressed (cf. 1:14-15; 2:23; Dan. 10:6). The image of eyes like “flames of fire” indicates Christ’s ability to search the minds and hearts of believers.

    PRAISE (2:19)

    This church is praised for its works, love, faith, and perseverance. They had continued growing and were doing more for God than they had done during the the first days of their faith.

    PROBLEM (2:20-25)

    Although this church was given high praise, it also had a problem with immorality. It tolerated immoral teachings. The reference to “Jezebel” (2:20) indicates sins of fornication and eating idol food, sins parallel to those practiced by the Israelites in their worship of Baal (1 Kings 16:29-33; 2 Kings 9:30-37). Again, the church was falling prey to cultural pressure to accommodate the pagan custom of idolatry. This pressure may have had its source in the commitment of trade guilds of that day to their patron deities. “Sickbed” (2:22) is a punishment for sin (cf. 1 Cor. 11:27-30). They will be cast into great tribulation so that the churches will know God as the one who tries hearts (17:2; 18:19; cf. Jer. 17:10; Matt. 16:27; Rom. 2:6).

    “Depths of Satan” (2:24) may either be a sarcastic reversal of the claim to know the deep things of God, or a claim to have mystical power over Satan by entering into his realm and showing him powerless. “Until I come” (2:25) refers to Christ’s second coming.

    EXHORTATION (2:26-29)

    The Lord’s exhortation to this church relates to rule in the Millennium. In 2:26-27 John quoted Psalm 2:9 indicating that “all who are victorious” will be associated with Christ in his kingdom reign (5:10; 12:5; 19:15; 2 Tim. 2:12; 1 Cor. 6:3). The context of Psalm 2 is very important, especially Psalm 2:7. True believers will share in Christ’s rule. The “morning star” (2:28) refers to Christ himself (cf. 22:16). In the Old Testament the concept functions as an allusion to an evil being (Isa. 14:12) and to the immortality of the righteous (Dan. 12:3). Again, “hearing,” and “listening,” and “understanding” mark the end of this and all the letters to the churches. This is also how Jesus ended his Sermon on the Mount (Matt. 5-7).

    Sardis (3:1-6)

    Sardis was situated in the western part of the Roman province of Asia about thirty miles southeast of Thyatira (see introductory map). The city stood on the northern slope of a mountain with a river flowing at its base. This setting rendered the city almost impregnable. Sardis was once the capital of the kingdom of Lydia. In a.d. 17 the city was destroyed by a great earthquake. Although rebuilt by Tiberius, Sardis never recovered its former glory and importance. The ancient city was noted for its fruits and wool. The making and dyeing of woolen garments was the chief industry of Sardis (cf. Rev. 3:4-5). Worship at Sardis had a sexual emphasis and focused on Sybele, a goddess similar to Diana in Ephesus. The church was probably founded during the time of Paul’s ministry at Ephesus (Acts 19:10).

    VISION OF CHRIST (3:1)

    The Lord is pictured as having the seven spirits and the seven stars (cf. 1:16).

    PRAISE (3:1)

    The Lord praised the Christians at Sardis for their good deeds (see also 3:4).

    PROBLEM (3:1-3)

    The Lord did not find the deeds of this church complete in God’s sight. Although the church had a reputation of being alive, it was dead on the inside. This is similar to the loss of first love for Christ (cf. 2:4). Again, as in 2:5, the remedy was to “go back to” (remember),”hold to” original behavior and teaching, and “turn” to God. Throughout the Old Testament, Israel was also called to “remember” and “return” to God’s redemption and commands. This is the most severe denunciation given to the churches. But this church had no named heresy or outside opposition, only incomplete acts of obedience to Christ (3:2).

    EXHORTATION (3:4-6)

    The Lord talked about future rewards to be given to “all who are victorious.” The righteousness of the “victorious” will be acknowledged by Christ before the Father (cf. Matt. 10:32). The “Book of Life” (3:5) refers to the book of the redeemed (cf. 20:15; 21:27). The concept of the “Book of Life” is seen in Exodus 32:32-33, Psalm 69:28, and Daniel 12:1. For “clothed in white” (3:5), see 3:18; 4:4; 6:11; 7:9, 13; and 19:14.

    Philadelphia (3:7-13)

    Philadelphia, located twenty-eight miles southeast of Sardis, was a wealthy trade center in the wine producing district of Asia (see introductory map). The city was situated on a 650 foot terrace above the banks of the Cogamus River at the threshold of a fertile plateau from which its agricultural prosperity was derived. Philadelphia was called “little Athens” because of the magnificence of its temples and public buildings. Dionysus, the god of wine, was the chief deity of the city. The believers at Philadelphia were commended for their deeds, their obedience to God’s word, and their loyalty to Christ (3:8). It is the only one of the seven churches of Revelation not subject to some measure of condemnation or criticism.

    VISION OF CHRIST (3:7)

    The Lord is pictured as holy and true and as having the “key of David” (3:7; cf. Isa. 22:15-25). This is a change from the usual reference back to the vision of Christ in Revelation 1:18. The “key of David” refers to Christ’s control over the messianic kingdom. The content of this letter is similar to the one to Smyrna. The readers were assured that Christ could bring them safely through persecution and into God’s kingdom.

    PRAISE (3:8-10)

    The Lord praised the believers at Philadelphia for their deeds. They had an open ministry (3:8) and experienced victory (3:9). They were promised to be kept from the “great time of testing” (3:10) in contrast with “those who belong to this world,” referring to the people who continue to reject the salvation of God (6:10; 8:13; 11:10; 13:8, 14; 17:8).

    EXHORTATION (3:11-13)

    The believers are reminded to hold fast until Christ returns (3:11; cf. 6:9-11; John 16:33; 17:15; Rev. 7:1-8; 12:6). Satan is the chief accuser and persecutor of Christ’s children (12:10; 2:9; John 8:44; 17:15; 2 Cor. 11:14-15). “All who are victorious” will gain a place in the new city (cf. 21:1-2). The “pillars” (3:12) may allude to the custom of honoring a magistrate by setting up a pillar in one of the temples of Philadelphia in his name. The writing of the name of God on those who are “victorious” identifies the believer as God’s own possession.

    Laodicea (3:14-22)

    Laodicea was located in the Lycus Valley on an important crossroads forty-five miles southeast of Philadelphia and about ninety miles east of Ephesus (see introductory map). The city prospered in banking, commerce, and the manufacturing of clothing made from the glossy black wool of the sheep raised nearby. It had a medical school and was noted for its production of a salve used to cure eye diseases (cf. 3:18). The church at Laodicea, with the other Lycus Valley churches of Hierapolis and Colosse, was probably established during Paul’s ministry at Ephesus (Acts 19:10), perhaps through the work of Epaphras (Col. 4:12-13).

    VISION OF CHRIST (3:14)

    The picture of the Lord in 3:14 looks back to that of Revelation 1:5. Christ’s work is certain (“Amen”) and his witness is faithful.

    PROBLEM (3:15-18)

    Laodicea (3:16) had no local water supply, so water was brought in by conduit from hot springs some distance away. The water no doubt arrived lukewarm, like the spiritual condition of the Laodiceans. The point is that the cold and pure waters of Colosse and the hot and medicinal waters of Hierapolis both could be put to good use. But lukewarm water was good for nothing.

    EXHORTATION (3:19-22)

    The Lord invites them to repent (3:20). Christ was depicted as outside the church, inviting the Christians within to receive him. In view is the final invitation to Christ’s messianic banquet (3:21). The believer is promised the privilege of sitting with Christ on his throne and reigning with him throughout eternity (22:5; cf. 2 Tim. 2:12).

    FUTURE EXPECTATIONS FOR THE WORLD (4:1-22:5)

    Overview: The third section of Revelation looks ahead to the future (cf. 1:19). Revelation 4-5 forms a prologue to this major prophetic section by providing a heavenly perspective for the earthly events to come. These chapters move from earth to heaven to provide a glorious vision of God that will pervade all the following chapters. The source of glory and judgment comes from a God who deserves ceaseless worship. Against the background of the adoration of God in heaven, the awesome events of the last days are revealed.

    This section shows the specific challenges involved in following Christ’s call to be “victorious” (2:7, 11, 17, 26; 3:5, 12, 21). It provides consolation and courage in the coming tribulation (2:10; 3:10; 7:14). It also gives insight into how history is run—not by human political power but by a God who is active and enthroned. In light of human and satanic persecution, the church appears unable to overcome earthly powers. But the scroll is the key to the end of such injustice and the beginning of God’s unhindered reign.

    The Perfect Source of Glory and of Judgment (4:1-5:14)

    THE SOURCE OF GLORY AND THE RESPONSE OF CEASELESS PRAISE (4:1-11)

    “Then as I looked” (4:1) is a recurring phrase referring to a movement from one vision to another (cf. 9:13; 15:5; “After this,” 7:9; 18:1; 19:1). John was invited to go to heaven for a preview of coming events. He did this by means of a spiritual vision. John was on Patmos but saw the glories of heaven. The “door standing open in heaven” (4:1) was used to show that John was going into a hidden realm to reveal what was unseen. These events are to be viewed from the perspective of heaven, not earth. John was “in the Spirit” (4:2), that is, caught up in a continued ecstatic state.

    The vision of God closely resembles the vision of God in Ezekiel 1:22-28. It also has links to Isaiah 6:1-5; Psalms 47:8; 104:2; and 1 Timothy 6:16. All the terrible suffering of the saints is to be viewed through the perspective of this vision of God’s glory and worthiness for worship. The “gemstones” (4:3) signify the first and last tribes of Israel in Exodus 28:17-21. In Ezekiel 28:13 these stones are counted among the treasures of the king of Tyre.

    There is considerable debate as to the identity of the twenty-four elders (4:4). Some interpreters regard them as a special order of angels. Others believe they represent the redeemed of all ages— twelve representing Israel and twelve representing the church. Since there were “twenty-four” orders in the Levitical priesthood (1 Chron. 24:4; 25:9-31), some have taken the number to be representative of believer priests. But in 5:9-10 the elders seem to be set off from those redeemed by Christ. In 7:13 one elder equals one being. It is probably best to regard them as human or celestial beings who have some responsibility for leading in heavenly worship (4:9-11; 5:8-12). Whatever their actual identity, their function in the book is clear. They were to reveal to the readers of John’s revelation the proper response to God—ceaseless praise and worship.

    For the “seven spirits of God” (4:5), see the note on 1:4. The thunder and lightning were reminders of how God appeared to his people at Mount Sinai (Exod. 19:16-18; cf. Pss. 18:7-14; 77:18). In Revelation the presence of thunder and lightning marks off important events and is always connected with the temple scene in heaven (8:5; 11:19; 16:18). The four creatures also function as leaders in unceasing praise for God as a background for the unfolding of his seven-sealed scroll of judgment (see also 5:9-10, 14; 11:16-18; 19:4). They are related to the cherubim of Ezekiel 1 and Isaiah 6:2-3. In Ezekiel’s vision of the glory of God, he saw four “living beings” (4:6) who were later identified as cherubim (Ezek. 10:15), an order of angelic creatures. These creatures are additional to the traditional orders of heavenly beings. Each of the four creatures had a unique face. One had the face of a lion, another the face of a calf, another the face of an eagle, and the last had a human face. Whether these are to be taken as four actual creatures or as symbols, their function is clear. They were involved in ceaseless praise. The specific focus of praise was needed by the readers of this letter, especially those undergoing difficult times.

    The creatures praise God for his holiness (4:8) and the elders praise God for his worthiness as Creator of all things (4:11). Seeing God in his holiness and Creator-sovereignty is indispensable for appreciating the upcoming judgment of the contrasting evil on the earth. The praise of a holy God results in seeing how bad it is on earth and how glorious it is in heaven.

    THE SOURCE OF JUDGMENT (5:1-14)

    Revelation 5 is a continuation of the heavenly scene. John focuses his attention on a sealed book in the right hand of the one sitting on the throne. The question of worthiness for judgment (5:2) is answered. The fact that the scroll is written on the inside and on the back indicates that there was a lot to say (cf. Ezek. 2:10). The drama of seeking a worthy opener heightens the importance of the sealed scroll. To break the seals was to open the scroll. The function of seals in the ancient world was to protect important documents for private and select viewing. This scroll is so confidential that it has not one, but seven seals. Only when all seven are broken will the contents of the book be revealed. The “strong angel” (5:2) will appear again in 10:1 and 18:21. The one worthy to open the seals would have to match the worthiness of the Father (4:11). The revealing of God’s judgment involves worthiness (5:2), not power. The challenge goes out to heaven above, earth beneath, and underneath the earth (5:3; cf. Exod. 20:4; Phil. 2:10). When the seven seals are broken, the judgments of God are poured out on the earth (cf. 6:1).

    The question “Who is worthy to break the seals on this scroll and unroll it?” (5:2) is answered in 5:4-7. Christ conquered (5:5), and his triumph serves as the model for the believers’ “victory.” Christ’s victory is explained in 5:9-10. Jesus the Messiah is the one who overcame death and thus demonstrates his right to open the book. The terms “Lion of the tribe of Judah” (5:5; Gen. 49:8-10) and “heir to David’s throne” (Isa. 11:1, 10; Rom. 15:12) are Messianic. Christ is the royal figure coming from the tribe of Judah and the descendant of King David. His victory, and that of his followers, is victory through righteous suffering, sacrifice, and conflict. The “seven horns” (5:6) are an image of strength (Zech. 1:18). For the “seven spirits of God” (5:6), see note on 1:4. Lamb (5:6) is used of Jesus in Revelation twenty-eight times (cf. Isa. 53:7; “our Passover lamb,” 1 Cor. 5:7).

    The worthy one is worshiped (5:8-14). “The prayers of God’s people” (5:8) relate to the prayers for the end of evil and the beginning of God’s kingdom. This is especially true of the prayers noted in the fifth seal (6:9-11). Both Father and Son are praised. For “new song” (5:9), see Psalm 98:1 and Isaiah 42:10. For being made “God’s kingdom and his priests” (5:10), see 1:6 and 20:6. The new song is sung by all heavenly and earthly creation (5:13). The universality of Christ’s work calls for this universal praise.

    Seven Seals Broken (6:1-8:1)

    Overview: Revelation 6:1-8:1 records the breaking of the seven seals of the scroll (5:2). It is important to realize that breaking only some of the seals does not open the book. The contents of the scroll are not revealed until after the seventh seal is broken. The events associated with the opening of the seals are simply an overture to the dreaded and final judgments of the scroll itself. The first four seals are the beginning of sufferings that lead up to the final great sufferings of the Tribulation and second coming of Christ. The first four seals relate to the events alluded to in Daniel 9, Matthew 24:4-31, Mark 13:4-37, and Luke 21:7-36.

    A WHITE HORSE (6:1-2)

    The breaking of the first seal marks the coming of the antichrist, the “little horn” of Daniel 7:8 or the “man of lawlessness” of 2 Thessalonians 2:3. The “bow” (6:2) may refer to a rainbow as in Genesis 9:12-17 and symbolize a conquest by peaceful means and diplomacy. There are similarities with Zechariah 1:8-17; 6:1-8. The figures of riders and horses form a stark contrast with Christ on a white horse in Revelation 19:11-16.

    A RED HORSE (6:3-4)

    This is the horse of war. The breaking of the second seal marks the removal of peace from the earth. The red color of the horse suggests bloodshed, and the “mighty sword” (6:4) confirms it.

    A BLACK HORSE (6:5-6)

    This is the horse of famine. There is a cause and effect relationship between the taking of peace at the breaking of the second seal and the increase of famine and inflation after the third seal is broken. The “pair of scales” (6:5) symbolizes the coming inflation and famine. A “day’s pay” (6:6; “denarius,” nasb; “penny,” kjv) is literally “a denarius,” which was a Roman monetary unit worth approximately one day’s wage.

    A PALE HORSE (6:7-8)

    Death results from war and famine. Ezekiel 14:21 is quoted in 6:8. These four seals are separated from the last three. They are preliminary to the opening of the scroll’s contents. The fourth seal reveals an ashen or yellowish-green horse that carries the horseman “Death,” resulting in the destruction of one-fourth of the earth’s population. Being eaten by wild beasts was one of the curses of the Mosaic covenant (Deut. 28:26).

    SOULS UNDER THE ALTAR (6:9-11)

    The fifth seal is now opened. The location is the temple in heaven (cf. Hab. 2:20). At the opening of this fifth seal the souls of martyred saints are revealed. They represent those who were slain for their faith. Their location under the altar shows that they are seen as a sacrifice. The answer to their question “how long?” (6:10) is that they must wait “until” (6:11) the final number of martyrs have died. At present, they are praying for judgment that has not yet come but will justify God’s reputation (cf. Pss. 79:10; 94:3; Hab. 1:2). The phrase “the people who belong to this world” refers to those who are against God (6:10; cf. 11:10; 13:8, 12; 17:2, 8; 3:10; 8:13). After the devastation accompanied by the first four horsemen (seals 1-4), the martyrs are revealed praying for God’s vengeance (seal 5). The sixth seal begins the vengeance requested by the martyred saints. The seventh seal reveals the scroll’s contents and the heart of God’s judgments. This relates to the purpose of the book by being a word of comfort for the redeemed during this and prior periods. The fifth seal is important because it implies that the first four seals were not divine wrath upon the unrighteous. This wrath would come, however, in the Great Tribulation seen in the sixth and seventh seals.

    HEAVENLY CATACLYSM (6:12-7:17)

    The breaking of the sixth seal unleashes universal havoc in the heavens and on earth (6:12-7:17). These cosmic disturbances characterize the day of the Lord and are predicted in Isaiah 34:4, Joel 2:30-31, and Matthew 24:29. The imagery used in these verses is from Joel 2:28-32. For the earthquake, see 8:10; 9:1; and Matthew 24:29. For the moon and sun, see Acts 2:20, Joel 2:28-32, Isaiah 34:4, and Mark 13:25-26. For the mountains moving, see Nahum 1:5 and Jeremiah 4:24. Those trying to hide from all this know that the day of God’s wrath has finally come (6:16-17). The term “wrath” (6:16-17) expresses a major characteristic of the day of the Lord (cf. 1 Thess. 1:10; 5:9).

    Before the final devastation is unleashed, God sets apart 144,000 sealed ones (7:1-8). Revelation 7 records a parenthesis between the sixth and seventh seals. From the severity of the judgments it would appear that not a single person could be delivered (6:17). The question was “Who will be able to survive?” (6:17). But the God of wrath is also the God of mercy. Revelation 7 records the manifestation of God’s grace in the face of his wrath by giving two visions of the sealed and the slain. This vision is between the breaking of the sixth and seventh seals, a pattern repeated between the sixth and seventh trumpets (10:1-11:13). For the “four winds” (7:1), see Daniel 7:2 and Jeremiah 49:36. There is a direct relationship between the sealing of these “servants” (7:3) and their safety. They are sealed for faithfulness and safety (cf. 9:4). The “seal” is a mark of ownership. It does not have to be visible to be real (Eph. 4:30). The 144,000 (7:4) are identified as coming from the twelve tribes of Israel. The tribe of Dan is missing, and Joseph is included instead of Ephraim. The important thing is that they are drawn from twelve groups. Since John did not reveal the function of the 144,000, any view concerning their role is conjectural. The point is that they and a great multitude will be kept through the Tribulation and will make it safely into the eternal kingdom (7:15-17). This may relate to the prophecy of Joel 2:3 (cf. 14:1, 3-4).

    John also sees a great company of Gentiles who were martyred (7:9-17) during the Tribulation (7:14). This is the group referred to in 6:11. In 7:15-17 John records the blessings to be enjoyed by the redeemed during the kingdom and the eternal state. For the Great Tribulation, see 3:10; 6:11; Daniel 12:1; and Mark 13:9. The concept of eternal service (7:15) is completed in 22:3. The tabernacle represents the new heavens and earth. For Jesus as the Lamb and shepherd, see Ezekiel 34:23 and Revelation 2:27; 12:5; 19:15.

    THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE SEALS, TRUMPETS, AND BOWLS

    The seven seals build up to the revelation of the scroll’s contents. The seven trumpets reveal God’s judgments. The fifth, sixth, and seventh trumpets are called the “woe” judgments (8:13; 9:12; 11:14). The seven bowls are the terrible exposition of the seventh trumpet (note 10:6-7; 11:15-19; 15:1; 16:17-21). The imagery of seven trumpets relates to the seven trumpets that sounded before Jericho (Josh. 6:4-5). But here when the trumpets blast, the world, not just a city, falls apart. Like the first seven-day creation, another series of seven will precede the new heavens and earth. Like the exodus, bowls of God’s judgment will bring release for God’s people. Like at Mount Sinai, God’s thunder, earthquake, and smoke (8:5) will signal his presence on earth. In the Old Testament, trumpets announced important events (cf. Zeph. 1:14-16). At Jericho, they announced the presence of God (Josh. 6:3). For the altar of incense (8:3), see Exodus 30:1-10; 1 Kings 6:22; and Hebrews 9:4. In Revelation 5:8 incense represents the prayers of the martyred saints for God’s vengeance. There is a direct link with the beginning of the trumpets and the prayers of the saints in Revelation 5. The contents of the scroll are presented as the answer to the martyrs’ prayers.THE SEVENTH SEAL IS OPENED (8:1)

    After the interlude of Revelation 7, the seventh seal is broken. The scroll’s contents are now revealed, framed within the seven trumpet judgments of God’s wrath (8:2-11:19).

    The First Four Trumpets (8:2-12)

    HAIL, FIRE, AND BLOOD (8:2-7)

    Casting the incense burner to the earth initiates the next series of judgments. The first trumpet is a judgment of fire. A third of the trees and all of the grass of the earth is destroyed.

    FIRE MOUNTAIN (8:8-9)

    The second judgment is upon the sea. A huge object is thrown into the sea that destroys one third of the sea life and one third of the ships. The mountain (8:8-9) and star (8:10-11; cf. Exod. 7:20) are from the coals of the altar (cf. Exod. 9:18-26).

    FIRE STAR (8:10-11)

    The third judgment is on the fresh water. Wormwood is a plant with a strong, bitter taste and is used as a symbol of bitterness and calamity.

     

    DARKNESS (8:12)

    God used darkness at several key points in his history of redemption (Exod. 10:21-23; Joel 2:2; Mark 13:24). The first four trumpets systematically unravel God’s work of creation in Genesis 1. The fourth judgment affects the sun and stars. Not only will the light diminish, but it appears that the day and night cycle will be shortened. In Joel 2:10 a plague of locusts darkened the sun and the moon.

    The First Two Woes (8:13-9:21)

    THREE WOES ANNOUNCED (8:13)

    The final three trumpets are trumpets of even greater woe than the first four. These signal the period of the great tribulation (Matt. 24:21-29).

    TORMENTING LOCUSTS (9:1-12)

    The “bottomless pit” (9:1) is seen again in 9:11; 11:7; 17:8; 20:1-3 (cf. Luke 8:31; Rom. 10:7). The fifth trumpet, identified as the first of three woes, is a judgment of locusts. The locusts are not ordinary locusts, for they attack people, not just plants, and their “king” (9:11) is Satan, the ruler of the demons (Matt. 12:24). See Exodus 10:1-20 for the locust plague at the time of the exodus. The prophet Joel drew a close comparison between the locust plague and the day of the Lord (Joel 1:2-2:11). Locusts were referred to as symbols of judgment throughout the Old Testament. Here the locusts torment like scorpions, that is, they are like scorpions in their power, not their appearance. As in the first four seals, the image of horses in battle is used again (9:7; cf. Joel 2:4-5). The locusts are seen as a terrible combination of man and beast. They only hurt those who have not been sealed (9:4). The trumpets are God’s wrath, which falls on none of God’s redeemed community. See Israel’s protection (Exod. 8:22; 9:4, 26; 10:23; 11:7). The locusts have power limited to five months (9:3-6). The point of this limited time is to still offer time for repentance (cf. Luke 21:25-26). Using the known reality of locusts, God has revealed the nature of the torment that is to come. “Abaddon” (9:11; cf. Job 31:12; 28:22) means destroyer. The Greek form of this name is Apollyon. Caligula and Nero claimed identification with Apollo, and Domitian, the persecutor of John, claimed to be his incarnation.

    MURDERING HORSES (9:13-21)

    The sixth trumpet, and second woe, brings death and destruction to a third of mankind (9:18). The second woe is introduced by the sixth trumpet. It comes as a voice from the altar, the place of the prayers of the martyred souls (6:9-11). The horsemen are described in 9:13-21. They are called plagues in 9:18. The Euphrates functioned as a source of battle and destruction for Israel (Isa. 8:5-8). It was the northern boundary of the Promised Land (Gen. 15:18). Note the lack of repentance in 9:20-21. Believers are spared (cf. 9:4). Under the fourth seal one quarter of the earth’s population had been slain, and here an additional third are to be destroyed. Though one-third of humanity is destroyed, the remainder still does not repent. The point for the readers in the seven churches of Revelation 2-3 is clear. Will Christ’s sacrifice and words of warning be enough to cause them to repent of their sins?

    The Little Book and the Two Prophets (10:1-11:14)

    Overview: Again, there is an interruption between the sixth and seventh elements in a sequence. Sandwiched between the sixth and seventh trumpets, Revelation 10:1-11:14 shows God’s answer to the lack of repentance mentioned in 9:21. He will no longer delay the end (10:6), and he will force his enemies to give him glory through the resurrection of his two witnesses and the accompanying signs (11:12-13). People may not repent, but they will give God the glory. This section answers two questions. The first concerns how much longer it would be before the judgments were finished (10:6). The second concerns the elaboration of further prophetic details concerning the events of the Tribulation and the kingdom to come (10:11). Although the seventh trumpet marks the end of the Tribulation (cf. 11:15), the book does not conclude there. John is told to prophesy again, focusing this time on the major characters and movements of the tribulation (cf. Rev. 13-19).

    DELAY NO LONGER (10:1-7)

    The “mighty angel” shows his signs of conquest (10:2-3, 5, 7). The mystery of the seven thunders (10:4) shows that there are still things to come that have not yet been revealed (see also 15:1; 16:17). The angel announces that there will be no further delay in the completion of God’s wrath and the inauguration of God’s kingdom on earth.

    THE PROPHECY PASSED TO JOHN (10:8-11)

    Eating the little scroll (10:9) was an allusion to Ezekiel 2:8-3:3. The New Testament speaks of other mysteries of God (10:7; Rom. 11:25; 1 Cor. 15:51; Col. 2:2; 2 Thess. 2:7). Here, the mystery has to do with all that is unknown concerning God’s prophecies of how he will triumph over evil and usher in his kingdom. The mystery of God refers to the program of God declared by the prophets that brings about the consummation of human history, specifically, the kingdom (cf. 11:15). Again, this is a message of exhortation to the present churches and an encouragement to those going through the tribulation.

    THE TWO PROPHETS (11:1-14)

    This vision is given in anticipation of a major construction project during the Tribulation—the building of the Jewish temple in Jerusalem (cf. 2 Thess. 2:4). Reference is made to the Gentile domination (cf. Dan. 8:9-14; Luke 21:24). To measure the temple and its worshipers (11:1) is to claim sovereign ownership and protection of them. Similar measurements take place in Ezekiel 40:5-43:17; Zechariah 2:1-13; and Revelation 21:15-17. Revelation 11:6 describes the power of these witnesses. Links are drawn to Moses (“blood,” Exod. 7:20, and “plague,” Exod. 8:12), Elijah (no rain, 1 Kings 17:1; 18:41-45; 2 Kings 1:10-12) and the witnesses in Zechariah 4:3, 11, 14 (olive trees and lampstands). The actual persons of Moses and Elijah were seen with Christ at his transfiguration (Matt. 17:2-3) and were mentioned in Malachi 4:4-5. The witnesses are protected by God’s power. They are presented as real people, though some interpreters view them as symbolic of the witnessing believers who are martyred during the Tribulation. The point is that God still continues to graciously offer salvation through men who genuinely mourn the evil state of the earth. The months and days mentioned in 11:2-3 may refer to the last three and a half years of the Tribulation. It is during the last half of the Tribulation that the Antichrist will overthrow Jewish worship and establish his own (cf. Dan. 9:27; 2 Thess. 2:4). The “beast” (11:7) refers to the antichrist (cf. 13:1). The names “Sodom and Egypt” (11:8) are used to refer to Jerusalem and suggest the spiritual condition of that city. God’s overall sovereignty is designed to encourage the readers as they go through their own tribulations.

    Seventh Angel Sounds (11:15-19)

    This trumpet introduces the third woe. With this trumpet, the kingdom of the world becomes the kingdom of the Lord. The content of the seventh trumpet is not immediately described. First, comes the great outburst of praise that summarizes the results of God’s final judgments. The covenant (11:19) appears to be the archetype of all God’s earthly covenants; it is the eternal covenant that asserts his right as Creator to be obeyed, to judge, and to redeem. Revelation 11:18 records different aspects of judgment based upon Christ taking his dominion over the nations. The wicked dead will be judged (cf. 20:11-15); the prophets and Old Testament saints will be rewarded (cf. 20:4-6); and the destroyers of the earth will be destroyed (cf. 19:19-21).

    The Dragon, the Beasts, and the Lamb (12:1-14:20)

    Overview: This section is placed between the seventh trumpet and the execution of the seven bowl judgments. The narrative flow of the book breaks between the sixth and seventh seals (7:1-17), the sixth and seventh trumpets (10:1-11:14), and between the seventh trumpet and the seven bowls (12:1-14:20). The breaks increase in length as the narrative moves closer to the climax of God’s seven bowl judgments. Each break elaborates the nature of the times and how God is punishing evil and preserving his saints even through death (13:10; 14:13).

    Revelation 12-14 contains explanatory prophecies and deals with the principle characters and major movements of the Tribulation period. These chapters elaborate the implications of the rage of the nations (11:18) for believers throughout history and especially during the Tribulation. Revelation 12 presents the persecution of Christians (12:17) by Satan. Its point is to stress the ultimate defeat of the devil and the triumph of faithful Christians (12:10-12). Revelation 13 details the persecution of Christians by Satan through his two beasts. Thus, in Revelation 12-13 the focus is on Satan’s war with the saints (12:17; 13:7; cf. 11:7). Revelation 14 proclaims and then illustrates the terrible fate of those who follow the beasts and the triumph of those who follow Jesus.

    THE DRAGON AND THE WOMAN (12:1-17)

    In Revelation 12 two signs are given. The first is a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon at her feet and a crown of twelve stars on her head (12:1; cf. Isa. 66:7-8). The second sign, an enormous red dragon, is given in 12:3. This imagery relates to an age-old desire for salvation. The slain Lamb (12:10-11) has a special place in Revelation 12. The victory is due to Christ alone, who is seen as the fulfillment of all pagan hopes. The conflict in heaven continues on earth. It unveils the activities of Satan and his angels in their attempt to destroy the Messiah and Israel. The woman with child represents Israel who gave Christ to the world (12:5) and will be severely persecuted during the tribulation (12:13). Satan’s ultimate objective is to destroy the woman’s child, Christ (12:4). The son of the woman (12:5) is Christ, as is seen by the fact that he is the ultimate ruler of the nations. Israel’s flight to the wilderness is designed to avoid the persecution of the antichrist during the last three and a half years (1,260 days) of the Tribulation period (Matt. 24:15-21). In Revelation 12:7-12 the scene shifts from earth to heaven. Satan and Michael, the archangel, are involved in a conflict. Satan and his angels are thrown out of heaven and are confined to the earth (12:9) for the rest of the tribulation period. He will now vent his wrath on earth. In 12:13-17, having been cast out of heaven, Satan will center his hostilities on the “woman,” Israel (12:5-6). His goal is to destroy Israel so that Christ will not have a people over whom to rule.

    THE TWO BEASTS (13:1-18)

    The Beast, or Antichrist, is Satan’s counterpart to what God offers the world in Christ. The Beast is a political figure who arises from the Gentile nations (“the sea,” 13:1; cf. Dan. 7:3) and receives his power and authority from Satan himself (13:2). The miraculous healing of the Beast’s death wound results in amazement and worship (13:3-4). The whole earth worships the dragon and follows the Beast to whom he had given authority (13:3-4). The Beast is given authority to engage in his evil exploits for forty-two months, the last three and a half years of the tribulation period. The “endurance” (13:10) is submission to the sufferings of the Tribulation without submission to Satan and his representatives.

    The second beast (13:11-18) functions to witness to the Antichrist (2 Thess. 2:4). He is referred to as the “false prophet” (19:20). This would serve as a warning against false prophets to the original readers of John’s revelation, just as it is for believers today. When God’s purposes are finished through the beast, he will be judged (20:10). The assurance that God will punish evildoers sustains the faith of the persecuted. The number representing the beast is identified as “666” (13:18). Many have sought to identify the Antichrist on the basis of this number, but such attempts will be futile until the Tribulation begins.

    THE TRIUMPH OF THE LAMB (14:1-20)

    These people, by way of contrast with those in 13:16, have the name of the Lamb and his Father stamped on their foreheads (cf. Joel 2:32). Revelation 14 continues detailing the age-old conflict between Satan and God. Although in Revelation 13 it may look like the corruption of the earth by the Antichrist is out of control, 14:1-5 tells the other side of the story. John tells of the 144,000 who have not defiled themselves with the beast’s religious system. The words “pure as virgins” (14:4) are probably a reference to the Beast’s religious system: the “prostitute” of Revelation 17. They are separated to God as women are separated to their husbands (cf. 2 Cor. 11:2).

    The three angels (14:6-12) continue to extend God’s grace for repentance (note Matt. 24:14). John recorded three angelic announcements intended to warn those on earth of God’s impending judgment. The first angel announced the “everlasting Good News” (14:6-7); the second angel announced the doom of Babylon (14:8; cf. Rev. 17-18); and the third angel announced the judgment on those who worship the beast (14:9-13). The fall of Babylon (14:8) is initially described in terms drawn from Isaiah 21:9 and Jeremiah 51:7. Babylon is mentioned throughout the book (Rev. 16:19; 17:5; 18:2, 10, 21; cf. 1 Pet. 5:13) and seems to stand for the world system that is totally against God and his people.

    John next recounts his vision of two judgments by God’s sickles (14:13-20). In the middle of the devastation of the Tribulation period, God gives his verdict concerning the martyrs: they are blessed (14:13). Using the imagery of harvest, the judgment on the earth is detailed. These verses are a preview of the judgment at the Second Coming described in 19:17-21. These two reapings may relate to the two reapings mentioned by Christ in Matthew 13:24-30, 36-43. The “city” (14:20) most likely refers to Jerusalem (Dan. 11:45; Zech. 14:1-5).

    THE RELATIONSHIP OF THE SEAL, TRUMPET, AND BOWL JUDGMENTS

    The seal and trumpet judgments brought partial destruction and afforded opportunity for repentance. But the seven bowl judgments dispense 100 percent judgment and zero percent opportunity for repentance. All is at an end; the evil are evil and the righteous are righteous (cf. 22:11). There are no pauses for elaboration. The bowls empty in rapid fire. This third series is explicitly called the “wrath of God” (15:7).

    The first four bowls are similar to the first four trumpet judgments, but they are more intense and complete the wrath of God. These judgments are poured out during a brief period at the end of the tribulation just prior to Christ’s second coming. The first bowl (16:1-2), like the first trumpet (8:7), is poured out upon the earth. This judgment of malignant sores falls upon the followers of the beast.The First Bowl Emptied (15:1-16:2)

    Another sign is now given. The wrath of God is completed in the seven plagues mentioned in 15:1. They are called seven bowls of wrath in Revelation 16. But before the final wrath, God provides a picture of final bliss for those who “had been victorious” (15:2-4). Those earthly saints are now connected with the place of God’s glory mentioned in Revelation 4. Being in the very presence of God is the goal for the exhortations to be “victorious” throughout the book. “God’s Tabernacle” in heaven (15:5) is the true tabernacle after which the earthly one was patterned (Heb. 8:5; 9:23-24). In Revelation 15:5-8 the temple is opened, the four living creatures again appear (cf. 4:6), and the temple becomes unapproachable in God’s judgment glory (cf. Isa. 66:6). Judgment is an expression of God’s righteous character (15:4; 16:7; 19:2). This chapter evokes images from the Exodus: the plagues, the sea, the song of Moses, the tabernacle of testimony, and smoke.

    The Second through Seventh Bowls (16:3-21)

    SEAS OF BLOOD (16:3)

    The second bowl, like the second trumpet (8:8-9), is poured out upon the sea but is more severe. As a result of the judgment, the sea is turned to blood.

    RIVERS OF BLOOD (16:4-7)

    The martyrs’ prayer of 5:8 is now being answered (16:6-7; cf. 2 Thess. 1:5-6). The third bowl, like the third trumpet (8:10-11) is poured out upon the fresh water so that it becomes blood.

    SCORCHING SUN (16:8-9)

    The fourth bowl, like the fourth trumpet (8:12), affects the sun. The increased intensity of the sun scorches the inhabitants of earth.

    DARKNESS (16:10-11)

    Even at this terrible point, people still resist God (cf. 13:1, 5-6; 10:10-11; 17:3). The fifth plague falls upon the throne of the Beast and brings darkness to his empire.

    EUPHRATES DRIED (16:12-16)

    The sixth bowl judgment will dry up the Euphrates River to facilitate the crossing of the armies of the kings of the east (cf. Dan. 11:44) as they rush to involve themselves in the campaign of Armageddon. “Armageddon” is literally “the hill of Megiddo,” referring to the hill upon which the ancient city of Megiddo was located. Megiddo was strategically situated at the foot of Mount Carmel to control travel through the Jezreel Valley.

    EARTHQUAKE (16:17-21)

    The wrath of God is completed (16:17). The great earthquake (4:5; 8:5; 11:19) destroys the city of Babylon. The city’s downfall is elaborated in Revelation 17-18.

    The Woman and the Beast (17:1-18)

    Revelation 17 describes the downfall of Babylon (14:8; 16:19) in greater detail. Babylon probably refers to the religious, political, and commercial aspects of the Antichrist’s empire. Revelation 17 focuses on the “prostitute,” the false religious system controlled by the beast of 13:1. Revelation 18 will describe the judgment on the Beast and his empire.

    The same angel will show the bride of Christ (17:1; 21:9). The Beast (17:3) appears to represent satanic influence throughout history. Its various heads are its attempts at world rule throughout history. The eighth head is the Antichrist of 13:1-10 (cf. Dan. 7:19-21).

    The “prostitute” imagery is seen also in Nahum 3:4 and Isaiah 23:16-17. This woman is to be contrasted with the woman of 12:1-6 and the bride of Christ (21:9). The prostitute is given a name that reveals she is the representative of the false religious system that began in ancient Babylon (cf. Gen. 11:1-9). The name is “mysterious” (17:5), that is, the city of Babylon on the Euphrates is not meant. This is a secret, or symbolic, use of the name, the exact understanding of which remains to be revealed (cf. 14:8; 16:19; 17:6, 18; 18:24). Names on foreheads (17:5) appear throughout the book for evil (13:16; 14:9; 20:4) and for good (7:3; 9:4; 14:1; 22:4). This vision answers a question asked by saints throughout the ages: Why do the enemies of God often seem so victorious instead of being judged? The vision shows that she will indeed be destroyed at God’s chosen time. The Beast and harlot’s descriptions function as guides to interpreting their destruction in 18:1-19:5.

    The seven heads, horns, and hills have been variously interpreted as Rome, other countries and kings, or simply as a symbol for all the kingdoms of history. More specifically, the seven heads are seven mountains or kings; five have fallen, one exists, and the other is yet to come. The first five kingdoms would include Assyria, Babylon, Persia, Greece, and Egypt. The kingdom in existence while John wrote was the Roman Empire (sixth). The kingdom yet to come will be the final form of world government. It is identified in 17:11 with the Beast’s own empire. The idea of “was alive and then died” arises from past and future expressions of Satan through rulers. “Ten kings” (17:12) may mean ten actual nations or may be symbolic for all the nations of the world.

    For “waters” (17:15), see Jeremiah 51:13. The destruction of the prostitute is described in images drawn from Ezekiel 23:11-35. Once in power, the beast and his associates will reject the authority of the prostitute’s system and throw off her rule. With that system destroyed, the Beast will then be introduced by the false prophet as the true god (13:12; cf. 2 Thess. 2:4).

    Babylon’s Downfall Described (18:1-24)

    THE ANNOUNCEMENT OF BABYLON’S DESTRUCTION (18:1-3)

    Revelation 18 describes the judgment on the final form of Babylon, the Beast and his empire. The imagery of Babylon falling is taken from Isaiah 21:9, where the ancient city of Babylon was destroyed.

    LAMENT OF THE WORLD OVER BABYLON (18:4-20)

    Revelation 18:4-20 is a message from “another voice calling from heaven” (18:4). The message begins with a call to separate from the city (18:4) and ends with a call to rejoice (18:20). The heavenly rejoicing forms a stark contrast with the world’s mourning (18:9-19). The prayer of the martyrs (6:10) is answered. The call to separate is to believers living in the Tribulation period who might be tempted to compromise their convictions and become associated with the Beast. The world’s leaders give three laments over fallen Babylon (18:9-10, 11-17a, 17b-19). Compare this with Ezekiel’s lamentation over Tyre (Ezek. 27). Half the commodities mentioned in 18:11-13 are mentioned also in Ezekiel. Mariners, kings, and merchants are also mentioned in the Ezekiel lamentation. The merchants mourn over the long list of commodities rather than their long list of sins. The judgment against Babylon is on behalf of heaven and the saints (18:20).

    BABYLON DESTROYED (18:21-24)

    The reason for the destruction is Babylon’s deception (18:23) and murder of the saints (18:24).

    The Marriage of the Lamb (19:1-21)

    THE GLORY OF GOD AND THE MARRIAGE OF THE LAMB (19:1-10)

    Revelation 19 begins with rejoicing in heaven by the angels and the redeemed. “Hallelujah” (19:1) is transliterated from Hebrew and means “Praise the Lord!” The Old Testament context of the verse quoted in 19:2 is Deuteronomy 32:34-43. The blood of the saints has been avenged (19:2; cf. 6:10). The Old Testament context of 19:3 is Isaiah 34:10. Many biblical texts describe the relationship between God and his people under the metaphor of marriage (19:9; cf. Isa. 62:4; Hos. 2:19; 2 Cor. 11:2; Eph. 5:25-33; Rev. 21:2). Here, John describes the marriage of the Lamb and the marriage supper. The wedding feast (19:7-9) is a reference to the end of the long and sometimes painful engagement between Christ and his saints. It marks the beginning of the eternal unbroken marriage relationship of perfect fellowship and love. This vision is here to encourage the readers through their tribulations with the vision of their ultimate entrance into God’s glory. The study of prophecy should witness to Jesus, giving believers a greater appreciation of his person and work (19:10).

    THE WAR OF THE LAMB (19:11-21)

    This is the second coming of Christ. Jesus the Messiah returns with his heavenly armies to execute judgment on his enemies and to establish his kingdom (cf. Zech. 14:1-5; Matt. 24:29-30). Jesus is referred to as the “Word” (19:13; cf. John 1:1). There is debate regarding the identification of the “armies of heaven” (19:14). Some interpret them to refer to the saints. More likely, they refer to the angels of heaven who are under God’s command (cf. Mark 8:38; 2 Thess. 1:7). The vision of the great banquet of God (19:17-21) describes the carnage resulting from Christ’s judgment on his enemies. This event is similar to that described in Ezekiel 39:17-20.

    A Final Rebellion Is Put Down (20:1-15)

    SATAN IS BOUND (20:1-3)

    Revelation 20 describes the duration, nature, government, and chronological sequence of events related to the Millennium. There are three main views regarding this chapter: (1) The postmillennial view interprets the chapter figuratively. The thousand years is understood to refer to a period of prosperity that will culminate in the second coming of Christ. (2) The amillennial viewpoint interprets the chapter symbolically. There is no literal period of a thousand years of Christ’s reign after his return because the reign of Christ began in heaven after his ascension. (3) The premillennial viewpoint interprets the chapter as referring to an actual thousand-year period. Christ will return and inaugurate a literal thousand-year earthly reign during which peace and righteousness will prevail.

    John observes that Satan is bound for one thousand years (20:1-3). This is so there will be no external source of deceit during the thousand years. Satan, the organizer of opposition against Christ, is removed so that righteousness and peace will flourish (cf. Isa. 11:3-5).

    JUDGMENTS FOR ONE THOUSAND YEARS (20:4-6)

    The martyred believers and perhaps others (see Dan. 12:2, 13; Matt. 19:27-28; 1 Cor. 6:2; 2 Tim. 2:12) are resurrected to share in Christ’s millennial reign. The rest of the dead are not raised until after the Millennium (cf. 20:11-15). This brief description covers one thousand years but emphasizes the blessedness of those who overcame temptation to give in to the Antichrist and thereby escape the horrors of the second death. Again, this encouraged the original readers of Revelation (and should encourage readers today) to view physical death as less important than risking the second and eternal death.

    GOG AND MAGOG DEFEATED (20:7-10)

    Satan is released for a final period of deception (20:3), which is magnified by the contrast of its absence during the thousand years (20:4-9). The Old Testament background is Ezekiel 38-39. This event is similar in purpose to the one spoken of in Ezekiel 38-39 and therefore is also called “Gog and Magog.” Satan’s followers are apparently those who were born in the Millennium but did not have true faith in Christ. As a result of this final rebellion, Satan is thrown into the lake of fire where he will stay throughout eternity.

    THE GREAT WHITE THRONE JUDGMENT (20:11-15)

    The Great White Throne Judgment involves the resurrection and judgment of what 20:5 called “the rest of the dead.” The record books are consulted to demonstrate that the judgment is deserved (20:12), and then the book of life is opened to see if their names are within and their deeds have been covered by faith in the shed blood of Jesus. The absence of one’s name in the book of life indicates that one’s destiny is the lake of fire, the second death.

     

    The Perfection of Creation’s Glory (21:1-22:5)

    THE NEW HEAVENS AND EARTH (21:1-8)

    The last vision of Revelation describes the new Jerusalem, which will serve as the abode of the saints throughout eternity. John saw the new heaven and earth after the present earth had been purged from the effects of sin by fire (Isa. 65:17; 66:22; 2 Pet. 3:10-13). This completes God’s promise to Abraham to give him a land. This does not refer to the partial fulfillment seen in the land of Palestine but to the advent of a new heaven and earth (cf. Heb. 11:10, 16; 13:14). The new Jerusalem comes down out of heaven to settle on the earth (Rev. 21:2). This city is to be occupied by “all those who are victorious” (21:7; cf. 2:7, 11, 17, 26; 3:5, 12, 21; 1 John 5:4-5). The judgments of the day of the Lord (cf. 2 Pet. 3:10-12) will melt into eternal peace. The glory of God’s children will have released the creation from its futility (Rom. 8:19-22). God’s presence will form the perfect and eternal tabernacle (cf. Lev. 26:11-12; Jer. 31:33; Ezek. 37:27; Zech. 8:8). The transformation of believers from glory to glory will be complete (2 Cor. 3:18; 4:16-18; 5:16-17). This functions as a motivating vision for overcoming the present temptations to deny Christ and his holiness.

    THE NEW JERUSALEM (21:9-22:5)

    The “bride, the wife of the Lamb” (21:9) is a reference, not to the city itself, but to its inhabitants (21:24, 27; 22:2-5). For the twelve gates (21:12), see Ezekiel 48:30-34. The city is portrayed with equal dimensions like a cube, significant because the holy of holies in the temple was also a cube (cf. 1 Kings 6:20). The image is of the perfect tabernacle of God (21:3), built from the ground up with the most precious of materials. In Revelation 22 the images of Eden return once again; the river and the tree of life (22:1-2; cf. Gen. 2:9; 3:22; Ezek. 47:12) appear once again. The promises to David are fulfilled in the believers (21:7; cf. 2 Sam. 7:14; 2 Cor. 6:18). In the new Jerusalem the faithful will behold what Moses and all people after Adam were denied; they will see the very face of God (cf. Exod. 33:20, 23; Matt. 5:8). Zechariah 14:7 spoke of a time when there would be no night (Rev. 21:25). The awful curse of God that fell upon the earth and humanity in Genesis 3 is now reversed (22:3). God’s bond servants can now perform what God wanted from his people from the beginning; God had created man to serve him for eternity (22:3). Nowhere in Scripture is there a description of the complete details of the believer’s eternal state (cf. 1 Cor. 2:9), but John provides believers with a foretaste of the glories to come. Heaven is in reality a new heaven and earth; it is a beautiful place where believers will enjoy fellowship with Christ, rest, joy, service, and worship.

    BLESSINGS AND CURSES (22:6-21)

    This epilogue returns to the themes of the prologue (cf. 1:3) and serves as the conclusion of the book. The prophecy was authenticated by the angel (22:6), by Christ (22:7), and by John (22:8-9). John was commanded to leave the book unsealed, for the time was near when people would need understanding of what God was doing (22:10). Revelation 22:11 reveals that when Christ comes, there will be no further opportunities to change one’s destiny. The term “dogs” (22:15) refers to persons of lower character. Jesus himself speaks again in 22:16. He identifies himself as the “heir to David’s throne” (5:5), the one with whom God would fulfill Israel’s covenant promises (Luke 1:32-33). An invitation by the Spirit and the bride was given to all who would thirst for the water of life (22:17; cf. Isa. 55:1). They were offered the free gift of salvation. In 22:18-19 John warned against additions or subtractions from the prophecy (cf. Deut. 4:2; 12:32; Prov. 30:6). The warning of 22:19 assumes that no genuine believer would tamper with the Scripture. For the third time in this chapter (22:7, 12, 20), the Lord said that he would come soon. John’s reply is also that of his readers, “Come, Lord Jesus.”

    —Tyndale Concise Bible Commentary

    3. Order and Scope of the Book of Revelation

    Introduction · Does This Book Apply to Us? · Various Opinions on the Order · A Biblical Approach · Literary Flow vs. Chronological Order · Not Appointed to Wrath?

    Introduction

    Attempt to understand the book of Revelation has given rise to a great deal of controversy. I think it is because of this controversy and the variety of opinions surrounding this book that so many ministers avoid it altogether. This is very sad because it is the only book in the Bible which gives a specific blessing to him “who reads and those who hear” its words (1:3), and it is an epistle written to the church (v. 4). The questions I want to address in this chapter are as follows: Does this book apply to us? What is its order? When does God’s wrath take place?

    Does This Book Apply to Us?

    First, I would simply like to point out that the book of Revelation is an epistle, written to churches. It begins with the same customary greeting usually found in the other epistles (1:4) and ends with an exhortation as usual (22:10-21). The first verse states that the purpose of this book is to show God’s servants the “things which must shortly take place” (1:1). Then three verses later we read, “John to the seven churches that are in Asia” (1:4). It seems that, in context, the servants he is referring to are those in the churches. Seven times Jesus exhorts us to “hear what the spirit says to the churches” and then follows by “to him who overcomes . . .” It seems to me that in the remaining chapters he goes on to describe what it is we are to overcome (the Great Tribulation). Even in the final chapter of the book Jesus again states its purpose, “I, Jesus, have sent My angel to testify to you these things for the churches” (22:16). It just seems logical to conclude that the events written in this book are for the church.

    Various Opinions on the Order

    The opinions range from a strict chronology to the idea that there is no sequence of events whatsoever. The first view is easily dismissed. For instance, Revelation 14:1 has Jesus standing on Mount Zion with the 144,000 Jews when the bowls are still yet to come in chapter 16 and his return in chapter 19. Revelation 11:15-19 states that Jesus has now received the kingdom and begun to reign, that the time for the dead to be judged has come, and that it is time to destroy those who destroy the earth. All of these are events which take place after the Tribulation. Revelation 7:15-17 seems to depict eternity (compare to 21:3-7). Revelation 10:7 states that with the seventh trumpet “the mystery of God is finished.” In 13:1 John first sees the Beast coming out of the sea which would be very difficult to reconcile with what has been going on if this is when he first appears (especially chapter 12). Revelation 12:4 is best understood as taking place in eternity past with verse 5 as a reference to the birth and ascension of Christ (although some would understand it differently). Revelation 14:17-20 describes the harvest by the angels which Jesus said would take place at the “end of the age” (Matt. 13:39). Both 14:8 and 18:2 describe the fall of Babylon as if it has just taken place. Revelation 6:12-14 describes the great cosmic signs which Jesus said would take place “after the tribulation” (Matt. 24:29). And both 6:14 and 16:20 describe the disappearance of all mountains and islands.

    Among those who fall between a strict chronology and the idea of no sequence whatsoever, there are two major schools of thought concerning how to understand the order of the book of Revelation. The first is the view which sees the seals, trumpets, and bowls as sequential with some of the events in between as being interruptions of this order. The second view sees the seals, trumpets, and vials as all leading up to the end. It sees this as the same story told from different points of view, similar to the different accounts in the gospels. Each time John describes events that lead up to the return of the Lord and the end of the age from a different perspective.

    A Biblical Approach

    Now the difference between these two views is very important to the discussion. I will attempt to show that the second is to be preferred. This is based primarily on the similarity of events described towards the end of the seals, trumpets, and bowls as demonstrated in the following chart:

    Sixth and Seventh Seal

    Sixth and Seventh Trumpet

    Seventh Bowl

    1. A great earthquake

    2. Voices, thunderings, lightnings, and an earthquake

    3. Angel cried with a loud voice

    4. Every mountain and island taken out of their way

    5. —

    6. —

    7. Day of his wrath is come

    8. Silence in heaven

    9. Great multitude in heaven

    10. —

    1. A great earthquake

    2. Lightnings, voices, thunderings and an earthquake

    3. Great voices in heaven

    4. —

    5. Great hail

    6. Temple opened; voices heard

    7. Thy wrath is come

    8. Mystery of God is finished

    9. Time of the dead

    10. Kingdom given to Christ

    1. A great earthquake

    2. Voices, thunders, lightnings and a great earthquake

    3. Great voice from heaven

    4. Every island fled away and the mountains were not found

    5. Great hail

    6. Great voice out of the temple

    7. Fierceness of his wrath

    8. “It is done”

    9. First resurrection (ch. 20)

    10. Christ reigns 1,000 yrs (ch. 20)

    Although some of these are debatable there seems to me to be overwhelming evidence here linking these events. The most logical understanding is that these are describing the same events with some giving more details and some leaving out details. This is more plausible than the idea that all these things take place multiple times. We could look at several of these events, but I want to focus on one in particular: I grew up on an island. Imagine that every island on the planet disappears. Now imagine that every mountain is leveled. Think about it: THIS CANNOT HAPPEN TWICE! Mountains and islands do not “grow back” after five or six years. If nothing else, at least these must both describe the same event.

    Not only do these events parallel each other, but they parallel other passages. For instance, the sixth seal parallels the description of the end by both Jesus and Joel:

    Joel (Joel 2)

    Jesus (Matt. 24)

    John (Rev. 6)

    1. In the last days (Acts 2:17)

    2. Sun into darkness, moon into blood

    3, 4. Wonders in heaven . . .

    5. . . . and in the earth

    6. Before the coming of the great and awesome day of the LORD

    1. After the tribulation

    2. Sun darkened, moon does not give its light

    3. Stars fall from heaven

    4. Powers of the heavens shaken

    5. —

    6. Then the Son of Man appears in the sky

    1. At the sixth seal

    2. Sun became black, moon like blood

    3. Stars of heaven fell to earth

    4. Sky receded as a scroll

    5. Mountains, islands disappear

    6. Jesus is seen / day of his wrath has come

    Jesus plainly states that the great cosmic signs would take place “after the tribulation.” John has them occurring at the sixth seal. We must therefore conclude that at least the sixth seal is after the Tribulation. Furthermore, the seventh trumpet (Revelation 11:15-19) clearly describes the end and is said to finish the mystery of God (10:7) as was already stated.1 Also, as John is approaching the seventh trumpet he is told that he “must prophesy again concerning many peoples and nations and tongues and kings” (10:11). This leads me to believe that the sixth and seventh trumpets bring us to the end, and then John starts back over from a different perspective listing different events with the bowls.2 Finally, it seems likely that this seventh trumpet parallels Paul’s last trumpet in 1 Corinthians 15:52 and Jesus’ trumpet in Matthew 24:31.

    Literary Flow vs. Chronological Order

    Although I do not see a strict chronology, I do see a literary flow of the book of Revelation (characters are usually introduced into the story before they are discussed, such as the 144,000 in chapter 7 and the great harlot in chapter 17). This order may seem strange to us, but it is not foreign to other passages in the Bible and fits very well with the Semitic style of the book. In the Olivet Discourse, Jesus describes the first 3 ½ years (beginning of sorrows) followed by the second 3 ½ years (Tribulation) and finishes with the coming of the end (Matt. 24:4-14). Then he returns to discuss the midpoint in verse 15 and the second 3 ½ year period again in verse 21. This is similar to the story of creation in Genesis 1 and 2. Moses tells the whole story and then returns to expound on the creation of man in more detail. This is how I understand the seals, trumpets, and vials. They are increasingly more telescopic of events leading up to the end.

    Not Appointed to Wrath?

    A major tenet of pre-tribulationism is based on exemption from divine wrath. Passages such as Romans 5:9 and 1 Thessalonians 1:10; 5:9 teach that God has spared believers from his orge (wrath) which he will pour out on unbelievers. The question then becomes, “When does the orge of God take place?” If we accept the order of Revelation laid out in the preceding section, then it only takes place after the Tribulation. This word is found only six times in the book, and it is always used in a post-tribulational setting.3 It accompanies the cosmic signs and revealing of the Lord at the sixth seal (6:16, 17); it is found after the seventh trumpet (11:18); it is used to describe the final torment of unbelievers in hell (14:10); it is found after the seventh bowl (16:19); and it is used in connection with Christ’s second coming (19:15). Therefore, there is no problem reconciling the promise of deliverance from God’s orge with a post-tribulational rapture. Every time this promise is made, this word orge is used. If the orge does not take place until after the tribulation is over and the church is raptured, then God’s promise is kept.

    Also, as Romans 5:9 points out, exemption from God’s wrath is not some unique, special promise to the church but is connected with salvation and justification. The reason we are spared from God’s wrath is because Jesus paid the penalty for us. If there will be Christians on the earth during this time period then they, too, would be exempt from God’s wrath. These so-called “tribulational saints” are said to: “have washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb” (7:14); overcome by “the blood of the Lamb” (12:11); “hold the testimony of Jesus” (12:17); “keep their faith in Jesus” (14:12); “die in the Lord” (14:13);4 be “witnesses of Jesus” (17:6); be “beheaded because of the testimony of Jesus” (20:4); and possibly be our “fellow servants and brethren” (6:11) if you include the church with “those who had been slain because of the word of God, and because of the testimony which they had maintained” (6:9). These people are Christians in every sense of the word. Concerning the body of Christ, Paul says “that there may be no division in the body, but that the members may have the same care for one another. And if one member suffers, all the members suffer with it; if one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it” (1 Cor. 12:26-27 ). One of the most troubling teachings of pre-tribulationism to me is a divided body of Christians with some on earth suffering while the rest of us just watch from a safe distance.5

    Some would still object because they see God doing things throughout the Tribulation. My response to this is twofold. First, I do admit that some of these “plagues”6 seem too universal for believers not to be affected. Israel felt the effects of the first three plagues while they were in Egypt, but God was pouring out his wrath on the Egyptians, not them. Noah was at least inconvenienced by the effects of the flood. Did God pour out his wrath on Noah? Or did God spare Noah? (2 Peter 2:5) Lot was affected by God’s judgment on Sodom and Gomorrah, but he, too, was the object of salvation, not wrath (2 Peter 2:7).

    Second, as was the case with Israel in Egypt, we do see God being selective at times. One place this is seen is when the bowls are poured out. The first is said specifically to affect those who had received the mark of the beast and worshipped his image (16:2), the third bowl is said to be for those who killed the saints and the prophets (vs. 5-7), the fourth results in men blaspheming God and not repenting of their deeds (v. 9) and the fifth is poured out on the throne of the beast (v. 10). These things are shown to be aimed at sinners, not believers.7

    Footnotes

    1. Compare to Daniel 9:24, where the completion of the seventieth week is said to “seal up vision and prophecy.” <back>
    2. Even pre-tribulationist J. Dwight Pentecost recognizes this point, cf. J. Dwight Pentecost, Things to Come (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Publishing House, 1958), 187-188. <back>
    3. The word thumos is also translated “wrath” and is found in places such as chapter 16. This will be discussed in chapter 5. <back>
    4. Compare to the rapture passage where Paul says that the “dead in Christ will rise first” (1 Thess. 4:16). <back>
    5. Pentecost appeals to this same passage to refute the partial-rapture theory which he says “dismembers the body” and “is impossible” but then has no problem with the church in heaven while “tribulational saints” are on the earth suffering, cf. Things to Come, p. 160, 212. <back>
    6. This is what the book of Revelation calls them (9:18, 20; 11:6; 15:1, 6, 8; 16:9, 21; 18:4, 8; 21:9; 22:18). <back>
    7. For a further discussion of wrath, see chapter 5, Wrath. <back>

    2. The Biblical Basis for Post-Tribulationism

    One Rapture Passage · “The Rapture,” a bad term? · 1 Thess 4:15-17 · 2 Thess 1:5-10 · 2 Thess 2:1-3 · Rev 20:4 · 1 Cor 15:50-55 · Matt 24:29-31 · Luke 17:26-31 · 2 Peter 3:8-15

    One Rapture Passage

    If we are going to try to decide when the rapture takes place then we must first go to the rapture passages and see what the Bible actually has to say about this event. Naturally, if we want to know when this event will take place we should look where it is discussed. The problem is that there is only one “rapture passage” in the Bible: 1 Thessalonians 4:17. Only Paul mentions the church being caught up in the air, and he only says it in this one passage. Therefore, this must be foundational to any discussion of the rapture. Since this is the only place in Scripture where the rapture is mentioned, all other passages that are taken to be “rapture passages” must have some connection to this verse. In other words, how would someone claim another passage as a “rapture passage,” without first proving that the same event is being described as is in the one rapture passage in the Bible? This is very significant to the discussion, because the next closest passage to this one is Matthew 24:27-31, which specifically states that it takes place “after the tribulation.”

    Another passage that is commonly referred to as a “rapture passage” is 1 Corinthians 15:52. Although I would agree that this is describing the same event, the rapture is not specifically mentioned here. The reason we connect the two is because similar events are mentioned. Both passages mention a trumpet and the resurrection of believers. Because of this, we conclude that these are both the same event. However, as I already mentioned, Matthew 24:27-31 has much more in common with the one clear rapture passage. Notice the similarities:

    Matt. 24:27-31

    1 Thess. 4:15-17

    1 Cor. 15:52

    1. Called he parousia, “the coming” (27)

    2. Jesus appears in heaven (30)

    3. Coming on the clouds (30)

    4. Angels present (31)

    5. Great sound of a trumpet (31)

    6. —

    7. Gathering of the elect (31)
    1. Called he parousia, “the coming” (15)

    2. The Lord descends from heaven (16)

    3. . . . with them in the clouds (17)

    4. Archangel present (16)

    5. Shout and trumpet of God (16)

    6. Dead in Christ will rise (16)

    7. We are caught up to meet him (17)

    1. Called he parousia, “the coming” (23)

    2. —

    3. —

    4. —

    5. At the last trumpet (52)

    6. Dead will be raised (52)

    7. —

    “The Rapture,” A Bad Term?

    It may come a surprise to some that the word “rapture” is not in the Bible.1 When we realize that Scripture does not speak of the rapture but rather says that at the coming of the Lord we will be raptured (caught up), it sheds new light on the discussion. It is misleading to speak of the rapture and then to ask when the rapture will take place. The Bible only mentions the coming of the Lord and says that when he comes we will be caught up together to meet him. But pre-tribulationists start by talking about the rapture and the second coming as if they were two separate events and then claim that post-tribulationists confuse the two. The fact is, however, that the Bible does not make this distinction. Instead, it uses the word “coming” (parousia) when we would expect to see the word “rapture” if indeed this were a different event.

    It is also interesting to note that the New Testament does use at least two other words to describe the return of our Lord, and once again no distinction is made. They are: apokalupsis, “revelation” and epiphaneia, “appearing.” Both of these Greek words are used as the hope of the church (1 Cor. 1:7; 2 Tim. 4:1,8; Titus 2:13; 1 Peter 1:7,13; 4:13) and in clear second coming passages (2 Thess. 1:7; 2:8).2 It would seem very strange then for the writers of the New Testament to use at least three different words interchangeably to describe two different events that are separated by seven years. In other words, it would be confusing to use these three words to speak of two different events without distinguishing the two events. We would expect them to use different words for different events (such as rapture and second coming maybe?). How are we able to distinguish what Scripture does not?3

    1 Thessalonians 4:13-18

    When we take a closer look at our “rapture passage,” we see that Paul is not describing a new event but is explaining that at the coming of the Lord the dead will be raised. Notice how he begins his thought in verse 13, “But we do not want you to be uninformed, brethren, about those who are asleep, so that you will not grieve as do the rest who have no hope.” This sets the tone for what he is about to discuss. It is what he will be addressing, his “thesis statement” if you will. We then see him develop his theme of the dead in Christ as he goes on:

    [14] For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so God will bring with Him those who have fallen asleep in Jesus. [15] For this we say to you by the word of the Lord, that we who are alive and remain until the coming of the Lord, will not precede those who have fallen asleep. [16] For the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. [17] Then we who are alive and remain will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so we shall always be with the Lord. [18] Therefore comfort one another with these words. [1 Thess. 4:14-18]

    Paul’s point to the believers at Thessalonica is that they need not worry about their dead loved ones. Jesus will resurrect them when he returns. He says that this will take place at “the coming of the Lord.” There is no hint that this is any different than the coming which everyone was expecting–the one that Jesus told his apostles would take place “after the tribulation” (Matt. 24:29). We would also expect that the eschatology Jesus taught them would be the same as what Paul was teaching, unless we have reason to believe differently.

    It is primarily this lack of evidence for multiple comings that is the basis for post-tribulationism. When it is realized that there is only one coming, post- is the only position. All agree that Christ is coming after the Tribulation, so if there is only one coming (or one stage of his coming as some prefer to call it), then the rapture must occur after the Tribulation.

    2 Thessalonians 1:5-10

    [5] This is a plain indication of God’s righteous judgment so that you will be considered worthy of the kingdom of God, for which indeed you are suffering. [6] For after all it is only just for God to repay with affliction those who afflict you, [7] and to give relief to you who are afflicted and to us as well when the Lord Jesus will be revealed from heaven with His mighty angels in flaming fire, [8] dealing out retribution to those who do not know God and to those who do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus. [9] These will pay the penalty of eternal destruction, away from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of His power, [10] when He comes to be glorified in His saints on that day, and to be marveled at among all who have believed — for our testimony to you was believed. [2 Thess. 1:5-10]

    As mentioned earlier, a frequent charge against post-tribulationism is that they fail to distinguish between rapture passages and second coming passages; however, since we never find the word rapture in the Bible, what we label as a rapture or second coming passage will depend on our view of eschatology. If we believe that the church will be raptured prior to the Tribulation then any passage speaking of Christ coming in judgment will be labeled a second coming passage and any passage which speaks of his coming as a hope for the church will then be labeled as a rapture passage. This can at times be arbitrary and even circular. However, there is at least one passage which positively links the two as one event. In 2 Thessalonians 1:5-10, Paul clearly states that God will give the believers rest when Jesus comes in flaming fire, dealing out retribution (v. 7,8). Then he goes on to say that the unbelievers will pay the penalty, “when he comes to be glorified in his saints on that day” (v. 9,10). There is no other conclusion than that the coming for the saints and the coming to execute vengeance are the same coming.

    2 Thessalonians 2:1-3

    [1] Now we request you, brethren, with regard to the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our gathering together to Him, [2] that you not be quickly shaken from your composure or be disturbed either by a spirit or a message or a letter as if from us, to the effect that the day of the Lord has come. [3] Let no one in any way deceive you, for it will not come unless the apostasy comes first, and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the son of destruction [2 Thess. 2:1-3]

    Once again, we see Paul laying out his subject matter at the beginning. He is going to be speaking, “with regard to the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our gathering together to Him” (verse 1). Then he states that the Day of the Lord,4 “will not come unless the apostasy comes first, and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the son of destruction” (verse 3). This is the most clear denial of an “any moment” rapture as one could imagine. There really is not much upon which to expound. This passage speaks for itself. But if I may paraphrase, Paul is saying, “With regard to his coming and our gathering, that will not happen until . . .” It also seems quite clear that Paul links the coming of our Lord with our gathering together to him, because he is going to speak with regard to both. I fail to see where in the passage Paul goes on to talk about the gathering after discussing the coming if we assume these are separate events.5

    Also, Paul is making a point here. He stresses in verse 3, “let no one in any way deceive you” (which is a double negative in the Greek, a very strong negation). He says this as if someone would try to tell them otherwise.6 But he is very emphatic for them not to be deceived, because it will not happen until these things happen first. “It will not come” is in italics in the KJV and NASB, thus signifying that it was supplied by the translators. However, it necessarily is demanded by the rules of grammar in the Greek and is thus translated by every major translation.7

    Furthermore, if we follow Paul’s flow of thought from verse one to verse two, he seems to link the “coming of our Lord” with the “day of the Lord.” Not only is this the most logical way to understand this passage, but in my opinion it fits best with all of the other “day of the Lord” passages which will have bearing later in the discussion.

    Finally, it would seem strange for Paul to tell them that the antichrist must come first if he knew they would not be around to see it. Why even say this at all? Why not tell them that the rapture must come first? It seems that he is warning them that this is what the church is to look for. Also, as we will see in chapter 7, this is how the early church understood this.

    Revelation 20:4-5

    [4] Then I saw thrones, and they sat on them, and judgment was given to them. And I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of their testimony of Jesus and because of the word of God, and those who had not worshiped the beast or his image, and had not received the mark on their forehead and on their hand; and they came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. [5] The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were completed. This is the first resurrection. [Rev. 20:4-5, emphasis added]

    That this is taking place after the Tribulation is obvious. People are sitting on thrones reigning with Jesus. Both sides are in agreement at this point. But what to me seems equally clear is that the Bible states this is the first resurrection. If the rapture is to be preceded by the resurrection of believers (1 Thess. 4:15-17; 1 Cor. 15:52), and this is the first resurrection, then the rapture must be after the Tribulation.

    For a pre-tribulationist this cannot really be the first resurrection. If the rapture takes place before the Tribulation, and the resurrection takes place before the rapture, then the first resurrection had to take place at least seven years before this time. They will usually say that this is the third or fourth phase of the first resurrection, which neither this nor any other passage teaches. The literal reading of this passage is that there has been no resurrection before this (aside from the Lord himself, of course). I fail to see what would be the significance of saying, “This is the first resurrection,” if there had already been several resurrections of believers prior to this time. The book of Revelation was written to churches, who had hope of a future resurrection. When they read, “This is the first resurrection,” the most natural thing for them to assume is that this is the one they were waiting for.

    Also, if the church is not included in this resurrection, then John never does mention the resurrection of the church. Why would he leave out such an important event, especially when it was to the church that he was writing? He would have left them wondering where they fit into this picture. Of course, the way in which one views the order of the book of Revelation has a bearing on the discussion, but this will be dealt with in the next chapter.

    1 Corinthians 15:50-55

    [50] Now I say this, brethren, that flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God; nor does the perishable inherit the imperishable. [51] Behold, I tell you a mystery; we will not all sleep, but we will all be changed, [52] in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet; for the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed. [53] For this perishable must put on the imperishable, and this mortal must put on immortality. [54] But when this perishable will have put on the imperishable, and this mortal will have put on immortality, then will come about the saying that is written, “DEATH IS SWALLOWED UP in victory. [55] “O DEATH, WHERE IS YOUR VICTORY? O DEATH, WHERE IS YOUR STING?” [1 Cor. 15:50-55]

    This passage and 1 Thessalonians 4:17 are probably the two most common passages people think of in relation to the rapture. We often hear it said that we will be caught up “in the twinkling of an eye” (verse 52). However, I think it will come as a surprise to many that the rapture is nowhere mentioned here. All it states is that a trumpet will sound, the dead will be raised and we will be changed. That’s it! This passage leaves us on the earth with changed bodies. Of course, I am not denying that Paul is describing the same thing here as in 1 Thessalonians 4:17. However, as was pointed out earlier, the reason we connect the two is because of the similar events that are taking place.

    It is also interesting that Paul begins this discussion with his statement about how the living will inherit the kingdom (v. 50). We know that this will take place at the second coming. It seems as though Paul is saying, “Even the living will be changed in order to enter the kingdom in glorified bodies.” This entire chapter is about the resurrection and Paul had already stated that you must first die to receive a glorified body (vv. 35-38, 42-44). Then he states in verse 50 that you cannot inherit the kingdom with a mortal body. The question naturally arises, “So what about those who are still alive when Christ returns? Will they be excluded from the kingdom?” Paul goes on to reveal the answer to this mystery by basically saying, “Look, those who are still living will not have to die to receive an immortal body but will be transformed while they are still alive.” Not everyone will have to die first, but everyone will be changed (v. 51). He goes on to say that this is because the perishable must put on the imperishable and the mortal must put on immortality (v. 53). When Jesus returns, even those who are still alive and in their mortal bodies must be changed in order to inherit the kingdom, because it is itself imperishable (v. 50).

    Verses 23 and 24 have been used by some to teach the multiple-phase coming that we discussed in the preceding section. With reference to the resurrection these verses state, “But each in his own order: Christ the first fruits, after that those who are Christ’s at his coming, then comes the end.” Now this does show multiple resurrections: Christ, those who belong to him at his coming, then the end. In other words, the resurrections are: the Lord himself, the first (general) resurrection, then the second resurrection. This does not show multiple phases within the first resurrection but seems to preclude such an idea.

    If the resurrection of “those who are Christ’s at his coming” takes place at the rapture, then John’s “the first resurrection” (Rev. 20:5) also takes place at the rapture, or it isn’t even mentioned here. It would seem strange that what John called the first resurrection–as if it were a very significant event–would be completely overlooked by Paul’s discussion of the order of resurrections. If indeed “those who are Christ’s at his coming” is a reference to the second coming, then either Paul does not mention the rapture (which would seem equally as unlikely, since he is writing to the church), or the rapture occurs at the second coming. That the latter is true is demonstrated by statements in the book of Revelation showing that those who die during the Tribulation would by all means be included in “those who are Christ’s.” This is seen in passages such as Revelation 6:11; 7:14; 12:11, 17; 14:12; 17:6; 20:4.

    Matthew 24:29-31

    [29] But immediately after the tribulation of those days THE SUN WILL BE DARKENED, AND THE MOON WILL NOT GIVE ITS LIGHT, AND THE STARS WILL FALL from the sky, and the powers of the heavens will be shaken. [30] And then the sign of the Son of Man will appear in the sky, and then all the tribes of the earth will mourn, and they will see the SON OF MAN COMING ON THE CLOUDS OF THE SKY with power and great glory. [31] And He will send forth His angels with A GREAT TRUMPET and THEY WILL GATHER TOGETHER His elect from the four winds, from one end of the sky to the other. [Matt. 24:29-31]

    As was already pointed out, this passage has more similarities to the one rapture passage (1 Thess. 4:17) than any other passage in the Bible. However, since it explicitly states that it is “after the tribulation,” pre-tribulationists claim that this is not the rapture, although they readily claim 1 Corinthians 15:52 as a rapture passage based on fewer similarities. Since they go to great lengths attempting to prove this, I must take some time in reaction to their position.

    One reason they deny that this is the rapture is the claim that Jesus was talking to the Jews here, and this passage does not apply to the church. Well, Jesus was talking to the disciples (Matt. 24:3), and it is true that they were Jews. Naturally, the gospel had not been given to the Gentiles yet, so most everything Jesus said was to Jews. Jesus lived in Israel. Whenever he spoke he usually was talking to Jews. If Jesus talking to Jews makes a passage inapplicable to us, then that would take out most of the gospels. In this instance, though, he was talking specifically to the disciples in private (v. 3). These men were the foundation of the church (Eph. 2:20). In my opinion they represent the church better than anyone. Furthermore, Jesus had already told Peter “Upon this rock I will build my church” in chapter 16 and given the disciples instructions for church discipline in chapter 18.8

    This discourse was prompted by their question, “What will be the sign of Your coming, and of the end of the age?” (v. 3). The disciples were asking him what they should look for in connection with his coming. Jesus went on to describe the Great Tribulation. The disciples lived after this awaiting his return and telling others about it. It does not seem reasonable to think that this was not really the coming they were to look for. Why answer them with a description of the Great Tribulation followed by a description of his coming in the clouds–with the sound of a great trumpet and the gathering his elect–if really they were going to miss all this by means of a pre-tribulation rapture? Would this not be what they went out and taught the church just a short time later?

    Also, they asked him about events concerning sunteleias tou aionos, “the end of the age.” Four chapters later, Jesus ends the Great Commission with the statement, “Lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age” (Matt. 28:20, emphasis added) using the exact same words and speaking to the same people, and everyone applies the Great Commission to the church. Furthermore, they were instructed to make disciples, baptize, and teach until “the end of the age” (28:19-20). The most reasonable conclusion is that the church will be here until the end of the age.

    Probably the main reason pre-tribulationists claim that this passage pertains only to Jews is that Jesus gives special instructions to those who will be in Judea at this time (Matt. 24:16-20). It seems that the reason he does so is because this is when the antichrist will break his covenant with Israel and set up the “abomination of desolation” (v. 15). This is very central to this time period and even marks the midpoint of the seven years. It is a key event worth discussing whether we are talking to the church or to Israel. Also, the Old Testament was the only Bible the disciples had at this time. He naturally builds on what they already knew. They had read in the book of Daniel about this time of great distress “such as never was” and about the abomination of desolation (Dan. 11:31; 12:1-2, 11). Jesus is adding to the knowledge that they already had.

    Since the antichrist will be in Judea at this time as he sets up the abomination in the temple, and immediately after this he will begin persecuting God’s people, then we would expect the Lord to give instructions for those who will be in Judea at this time. This does not make the entire discourse a “Jewish passage.” Also, part of the disciples’ question was about the destruction of the temple (v. 3) which is in Israel.

    It is also interesting that Jesus said in verse 9, “Then they will deliver you to tribulation” [emphasis added]. Tribulation, then, is not the “wrath of God” but is the persecution of man. Tribulation is what Christians suffer for being Christians.9

    Also, we have no reason to believe that what Jesus taught here is any different from what Paul later taught about the Lord’s coming (1 Thess. 4:17; 1 Cor. 15:23, 50-52). If I was a first–century Christian and heard Paul talk about the parousia of the Lord for the first time, I would have no idea that he meant a completely different event. He uses the same words, describes the event in an amazingly similar manner, and gives us no reason to think he had anything else in view. Basically, what I am saying is that the eschatology Jesus gave Paul is the same as the eschatology he gave the other disciples here.

    Furthermore, when we combine this with what Jesus went on to say about his parousia, it seems inescapable that he is speaking of the same event:

    [27] For just as the lightning comes from the east and flashes even to the west, so will the coming of the Son of Man be. . . . [30] And then the sign of the Son of Man will appear in the sky, and then all the tribes of the earth will mourn, and they will see the SON OF MAN COMING ON THE CLOUDS OF THE SKY with power and great glory. [31] And He will send forth His angels with A GREAT TRUMPET and THEY WILL GATHER TOGETHER His elect from the four winds, from one end of the sky to the other. . . . [37] For the coming of the Son of Man will be just like the days of Noah. [38] For as in those days before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day that Noah entered the ark, [39] and they did not understand until the flood came and took them all away; so will the coming of the Son of Man be. [40] Then there will be two men in the field; one will be taken and one will be left. [41] Two women will be grinding at the mill; one will be taken and one will be left.10 [Matt. 24:27, 30-31, 37-41]

    Luke 17:26-31

    In a very similar account in Luke, Jesus again compared his coming to the days of Noah and of Lot:

    [26] And just as it happened in the days of Noah, so it will be also in the days of the Son of Man: [27] they were eating, they were drinking, they were marrying, they were being given in marriage, until the day that Noah entered the ark, and the flood came and destroyed them all. [28] It was the same as happened in the days of Lot: they were eating, they were drinking, they were buying, they were selling, they were planting, they were building; [29] but on the day that Lot went out from Sodom it rained fire and brimstone from heaven and destroyed them all. [30] It will be just the same on the day that the Son of Man is revealed. [31] On that day, the one who is on the housetop and whose goods are in the house must not go down to take them out. [Luke 17:26-31, emphasis added]

    Here Jesus shows that God came in judgment on the same day that the believers were saved. Then he says that “it will be just the same on the day that the Son of Man is revealed” (v. 30). My point is that the rescue and the destruction both happen on the same day. Both the rapture of the church and the coming in judgment happen at the same time. When Jesus returns it will be a “blessed hope” (Titus 2:13) to those who know him and judgment to those who don’t (2 Thess. 1:7-8).

    2 Peter 3:8-15

    [8] Now, dear friends, do not let this one thing escape your notice, that a single day is like a thousand years with the Lord and a thousand years are like a single day. [9] The Lord is not slow concerning his promise, as some regard slowness, but is being patient toward you, because he does not wish for any to perish but for all to come to repentance. [10] But the day of the Lord will come like a thief; when it comes, the heavens will disappear with a horrific noise, and the celestial bodies will melt away in a blaze, and the earth and every deed done on it will be laid bare. [11] Since all these things are to melt away in this manner, what sort of people must we be, conducting our lives in holiness and godliness, [12] while waiting for and hastening the coming day of God? Because of this day, the heavens will be burned up and dissolve, and the heavenly bodies will melt away in a blaze! [13] But, according to his promise, we are waiting for new heavens and a new earth, in which righteousness truly resides. [14] Therefore, dear friends, since you are waiting for these things, strive to be found at peace, without spot or blemish, when you come into his presence. [15] And regard the patience of our Lord as salvation, just as also our dear brother Paul wrote to you, according to the wisdom given him, [16] speaking of these things in all his letters. [2 Peter 3:8-15, NET Bible]

    This passage has traditionally been understood to be describing events after the Millennium. Because of this, the “day of the Lord” has been understood to continue through the Millennium with these events taking place at the end. It is difficult to understand in this way when it is described as coming “like a thief” (v. 10). Plus this phrase “like a thief” is usually used with reference to the second coming of Christ. Also, Peter seems to be describing an event that the believers are presently waiting for (v. 12, 14) and which is connected with God’s promise (v. 9). Furthermore, he states that Paul wrote of these things in his letters as well. All of this does not support a post-millennial event. Their basis for a post-millennial understanding is the reading “burned up” in verse 10 (KJV, NASB11). This is translated from the word katakaio. The idea is that if the earth is going to be burned up at this time, then this could not take place before the Millennium, because Christ is going to rule on this present earth for a thousand years during the Millennium.

    However, the reading “burned up” is probably not original. There are several variant readings in the Greek manuscripts, and many translations favor the reading heurethesetai such as the NIV and NET, “laid bare;” the NLT, “exposed to judgement;” the NRSV, “disclosed;” and the NAB, “found out.” This is also the reading favored by the NA27/USB4 Greek Text. Concerning this variant the NET Bible comments:

    One of the most difficult textual problems in the NT is found in v. 10. The reading heurethesetai, which enjoys by far the earliest and best support (aleph B K P 1241 1739text et alli) is nevertheless so difficult a reading that many scholars regard it as nonsensical. As Bauckham has pointed out, solutions to the problem are of three sorts: (1) conjectural emendation (which normally speaks more of the ingenuity of the scholar who makes the proposal than of the truth of the conjecture, e.g., arga for erga with the meaning, “the earth and the things in it will be found useless”); (2) adoption of one of several variant readings (all of which, however, are easier than this one and simply cannot explain how this reading arose, e.g., the reading of P72 which adds luomena to the verb – a reading suggested no doubt by the threefold occurrence of this verb in the surrounding verses: “the earth and its works will be found dissolved”; or the simplest variant, the reading of the Sahidic MSS, ouch preceding heurethesetai – “will not be found”); or (3) interpretive gymnastics which regards the text as settled but has to do some manipulation to its normal meaning. Bauckham puts forth an excellent case that the third option is to be preferred and that the meaning of the term is virtually the equivalent of “will be disclosed,” “will be manifested.” Thus, the force of the clause is that “the earth and the works [done by men] in it will be stripped bare [before God].” We might add that the unusualness of the expression is certainly in keeping with Peter’s style throughout this little book. Hence, what looks to be suspect because of its abnormalities, upon closer inspection is actually in keeping with the author’s stylistic idiosyncrasies. The meaning of the text, then, is that all but the earth and men’s works will be destroyed. Everything will be removed so that humanity will stand naked before God.12

    On the translation “celestial bodies” for stoicheia in verses 10 and 12, it comments:

    Grk “elements.” Most commentators are agreed that “celestial bodies” is meant, in light of this well-worn usage of stoicheia in the second century and the probable allusion to Isa 34:4 (text of Vaticanus). See Bauckham, Jude, 2 Peter, 315-16 for discussion.13

    If we accept the reading of these translations, then the passage is not saying that the earth will be burned up but that the heavenly bodies will be dissolved, and the earth and mankind will alone be left before God. This is quite in harmony with Jesus’ description of the second coming. Alluding to Joel 2:31, he said that the sun and moon will be darkened and the powers of the heavens will be shaken (Matt. 24:29). Isaiah 34:4 and Revelation 6:14 add that during this time the sky is rolled up like a scroll (compare “the heavens will disappear,” 2 Peter 3:10). The Old Testament ties the darkening of the sun and the moon with the stars as well in passages such as Isaiah 13:10, Ezekiel 32:7-8, and Joel 2:10; 3:15. Isaiah 60:2 states that darkness will cover the earth before the glory of the Lord appears. Joel 2:2, Zephaniah 1:15, and Amos 5:18-20 describe the day of the Lord as a day of darkness.

    So if the events in this passage take place at the second coming, and if these events were what the believers in this epistle were to look for, then our hope and our expectation is the second coming. That the latter is true is evident in such places as verses 9 and 10: “The Lord is not slow concerning his promise . . . but the day of the Lord will come.” If we follow Peter’s flow of thought, it as though the promise in view here is fulfilled in the day of the Lord. The church is to be looking for and expecting the event described in this passage. Verses 12 and 14 state that we should be waiting for and hastening the coming of this day. Concerning the latter verse the NET further comments:

    The Greek verb used in the phrase strive to be found is the same as is found in v. 10, translated “laid bare.” In typical Petrine fashion, a conceptual link is made by the same linkage of terms. The point of these two verses thus becomes clear: when the heavens disappear and the earth and its inhabitants are stripped bare before the throne of God, they should strive to make sure that their lives are pure and that they have nothing to hide.14

    The conclusion we must draw, then, is that the church is expecting to see these events take place and should strive to be ready when they happen. This would hardly be applicable with a pre-tribulation rapture scenario.

    Footnotes

    1. Actually, we get the noun “rapture” from the Latin Vulgate where the verb harpadzo “caught up” is translated as “raptus.” My problem is not so much with the word itself, but, since this is a verb and not a noun, it is a reference to the action “caught up” which takes place at the event “the coming,” not to the event itself. Using the noun “rapture” in our discussion leads one to believe that this is an event in and of itself. In fact, I have seen Pre-Tribulationists even make the statement, “The Bible never says that the rapture will take place after the Tribulation.” This is a meaningless statement, since the Bible never uses the term. <back>
    2. These Greek words are not always translated “revelation” and “appearing” in each of these occurrences. This is simply their usual translation. <back>
    3. Furthermore, the rapture has traditionally been taught to be a secret event so as to distinguish it from the second coming where the Lord is revealed in all his glory. Therefore, it would seem strange to use the words “revelation” or “appearing” for this event. These words better describe the second coming. This is why Pre-Tribulationists used to say that the “revelation” and “appearing” were specific references to the second coming after the Tribulation. However, as we have seen, Scripture does not allow for this distinction. <back>
    4. The King James, following the Textus Receptus, reads “Day of Christ.” <back>
    5. It is interesting as well that when he speaks of “our gathering together unto him,” he uses the word episunagoge which is the cognate noun of episunago, the word Jesus used when he spoke of gathering together his elect in Matt. 24:31. <back>
    6. Compare also to the warning in 2:15 & 3:14-15. <back>
    7. See E. W. Bullinger, Figures of Speech used in the Bible (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker), 52-53. <back>
    8. 16:18 and 18:17. It is also interesting these two verses are the only occurrences of the word ekklesia (church) in any of the gospels. <back>
    9. See chapter 5, Tribulation. <back>
    10. For a discussion of this word “taken” see chapter 5, Take. <back>
    11. The NASB reads, “some ancient manuscripts read discovered” in a footnote. <back>
    12. NET Bible (N.p.: Biblical Studies Press, 1999), 732, note 2. For information see: www.NETBible.com. <back>
    13. Ibid, 731, note 12. <back>
    14. Ibid, 732-733, note 17. <back>

    Post-Tribulation Rapture

    This doctrine holds that there is a Resurrection-Rapture of living believers in Jesus Christ at the end of the age (or the “End time“). Post-tribulationists believe that Christians will remain on the Earth through the three and a half year great tribulation period. This period starts at the Abomination of Desolation and ends at the Battle of Armageddon. They will be gathered by the angels to meet Christ in the air (raptured) at Christ’s second coming immediately after the great tribulation just before the battle of Armageddon and then return with Him as Christ descends to the Earth, to usher in the Millennium (World to Come) on earth.

    Matthew 24:29-31 ASV 1 Thessalonians 4:15-17 ASV
    29But immediately after the tribulation of those days the sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken: 30and then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. 31And he shall send forth his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other. 15For this we say unto you by the word of the Lord, that we that are alive, that are left unto the coming of the Lord, shall in no wise precede them that are fallen asleep. 16For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven, with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first; 17then we that are alive, that are left, shall together with them be caught up in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever be with the Lord.

    For additional references, see also the parallel passages from Mark 13:24-27 and Luke 21:20-28. While the passages in Luke 21 parallels Matthew and Mark, it offers a couple of interesting clarifications. This passage in Luke offers interesting references to some of the major events which are greatly elaborated on in the Book of Revelation. Reading all three Books of the Bible in parallel, it would appear that Luke elaborates on the “abomination of desolation” describing Jerusalem being surrounded by the armies of the world and of Jerusalem’s imminent destruction (Luke 21:20).

    Another account which lends support to the idea of a post-tribulation rapture is in 2 Peter 3:10-13, where the idea of the “Day of the Lord” coming as a “thief in the night” comes from. This idea of imminence, according to the post-tribulation view, only applies to the wicked and the spiritually unprepared people that are still alive before the Return of Christ. Therefore, only God’s elect (Christians) will fully have a clear understanding of the timing of the second coming, and therefore Christ’s coming will not catch the believers by surprise, but only those who are spiritually ignorant regarding the truth.[1][2][3][4][5] In the passage of 2 Peter 3:10-13, Christ’s return is equated with the “elements being melted”, and “the earth also and the works therein shall be burned up”. Opposing views are not non-existent within the realm of Christian Eschatology. Two opposing views, pre-tribulationism and mid-tribulationism, see the rapture and the Second Coming (or Greek, paraousia) of Christ as separate events; while in post-tribulationism the two events are identical or simultaneous.

    Another key difference between the pre-, mid-, and post-tribulation lines of theology is the number of times that Jesus Christ must return. Although it is not directly referenced, in both the pre- and mid-tribulation raptures, Christ must then return a third time, at the end of the Tribulation period.

    The belief is that God’s Elect from all ages will be translated from mortal bodies into immortal glorified bodies at the Second Coming of Christ and that this will be at the end of the age. This event, it is believed, will come at the conclusion of what is termed the 70th Week of Daniel, the final seven years of this present age. This view was held by the early Church Fathers and has been held by Christians since that time. The doctrine of the Post-Tribulation Rapture is today held by a growing number of evangelical Christians. For Post-Tribulationists concerned about the recent decline of Christian faith, doctrine, and morals in the western church, an important reason to advance the Post-Tribulation Rapture doctrine relates to the importance of preparation of believers for “witness under trial”.

    The “witness under trial” issue was of major concern to evangelist Corrie Ten Boom, whose family suffered in Nazi prison camps during World War II for the crime of protecting Jews. Corrie Ten Boom preached that the Pre-Tribulation Rapture would leave the Christian church ill-prepared for witness under persecution, just as it had in China when Mao Zedong rose to power, and warned that Pre-Tribulationism was the sort of false doctrine that Jesus warned about.

    Another idea is that following the Great Tribulation, the False Prophet, or “The Beast out of the Earth” and the Antichrist or “The Beast out of the Sea” will be condemned upon Jesus Christ’s return, and all those who endured or died for Christ‘s return will be raptured to heaven and, following the Millennium, Satan will be condemned and the remaining dead believers will be raised and raptured into the new heaven.

    Post-tribulationists broadly base their doctrine on the complementary concepts that a two phase pre-Tribulation rapture is never mentioned explicitly in the Bible,[6] and that the “whole counsel of Scripture”[7] seems to clearly teach that the resurrection and rapture of the Church will be the result of the visible, physical Second Coming of Jesus Christ to Earth and that Christians are to look and watch for that event.[8]

    Matthew 24:29-31 and 1 Thessalonians 4:15-17 both mention the same actors (Jesus, his angels) and the same events (Jesus coming, the trumpet of God, and the gathering of the elect) in the same order. The latter passage written by the Apostle Paul is seen as being based on the former because of the usage of “by the word of the Lord” in verse 15[9] and that they are talking about the same event, but the first passage is explicitly dated “after the Tribulation”, and the second is where we get the term Rapture.[10]

    Contrasting opinion maintains that the passages are not talking about the same event despite some similarities because of details that are absent between the two passages and that the rapture event was a “mystery” until it was revealed in First Corinthians which the Thessalonian recipients would have been unaware of.[11]

    Post-Tribulationists respond to the opposing views of Pre-Tribulationists in a variety of ways:

    Some Post-tribulationalists see the Rapture and the Second Coming of Christ as part of one main event.[12][13] Support for this claim is found in 2 Thessalonians 2:1-3 in part because of the way the Apostle Paul introduces his topic, “Now concerning the coming of our Lord and our gathering together with him.” This was an ancient way of introducing your topic of discussion and later Paul refers back to the two nouns at least twice as “the Day of the Lord” or “that day.” Thus, “the coming” and “gathering” seem to be two ways of referring to one event, “the day of the Lord.”[14]

    It seems impractical for Paul to go to great lengths describing the coming of the Antichrist (and the falling away) to the Thessalonians[15] in order to calm them down that the day of Christ’s reign on earth had not happened yet if they were not going to be there for it as maintained by the pre-tribulational position. He would be more comforting by reminding them that they wouldn’t be present for it[16] than to precisely detail his recognition and say “Don’t let anyone deceive you in any way, for that day will not come until the rebellion occurs and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the man doomed to destruction”.[17]

    The most common passage used in defending a pre-tribulational position is 1 Thessalonians 4. This passage alone does not mention where the gathered ones finally end up but that those who are alive will be caught up to meet Christ in the air and always be with the Lord.[18] Rather it mentions the dead rising, Christ’s coming, angels, the trumpet of God along with the gathering of the elect and all of these participants are present in Matthew 24:30-31 31, which is clearly a Second Coming passage even agreed to by pre-tribulationalists. The author, the Apostle Paul says the Rapture will occur “at the last trumpet”.[19] To be consistent with Revelation 11 this trumpet call must occur after the Tribulation. In the same way, Revelation 21 mentions the first resurrection after the Second Coming in Revelation 19. By definition, there can be no trumpet call after the last one, and no resurrection before the first.

    Linguistic support for a one-event 2nd Coming are in the words “meet” and “coming” in 1 Thessalonians 4. The meet in 1 Thessalonians 4:17 and in Matthew 25:1 (a Second Coming parable) refers to the custom of people going out to meet a dignitary as he was approaching their city before he got there, and accompanying or welcoming him back to where they came from.[9] This is also the usage in Acts 28:15 of those going out to meet Paul as he headed toward them in Rome. Also, the Greek term parousia[20] has the idea of a grand dignitary making his arrival to a certain location. The rest of the passage supports this grand arrival with His coming being heralded with trumpet, angels, and a surging ‘city’ of gathered believers going out to meet Him. Who more grand than the Lord Jesus Christ at His coming to reign on earth? This passage lends more weight to the post-tribulational position.[16]

    Another strength for this position is Paul saying when the church would receive rest for its suffering.[21] It would take place at the revealing of Jesus Christ with fire and judgment and at this time those who were afflicting the church at Thessalonica would be repaid for such treatment. No mention is made of a Pre-tribulational removal but that rest comes at His Coming and so does judgment.[22]

    A passage much debated regarding the timing of the Rapture is Revelation 3:10, which speaks of the Philadelphian church being “kept from the hour of trial which is about to come upon the whole earth to test those who dwell on the earth.”[23] The debate centers around the phrase “kept from” which could be taken to mean “physical removal from” (Pre-trib) or “preservation from or in the midst of” (Post-trib).[24] However it is interesting to note that the verse denotes that the testing is for “those who dwell on the earth.” This is a common phrase referring to unbelievers.[25] What we see later in Revelation, on at least 3 occasions, is that the saints are “sealed” and kept out of harm’s way when God pours out specific judgments which only affect His unbelieving enemies.[25][26][27]

    Linguistic highlight the idea that Christians are preserved by God through tribulation rather than removed:

    I pray not that thou shouldest take them out of the world, but that thou shouldest keep them from the evil.[28]

    This passage is one of the most blunt verses, showing that Jesus himself did not want the Christians taken out of the world in order to protect them from evil but had the intention of preservation in the midst of it. This is a place where pre-tribulationism lacks linguistic favor because this verse and Revelation 3:10 are the only places where the exact phrase tereo ek translated from Greek into keep from are found and that by the same author, the disciple John.[29]

    The pretribulational argument that there are ‘two phases’ to Christ’s coming (a Rapture and a later Second Advent)[30] runs into difficulties with Acts 1:11, which nearly equates Christ’s Ascension to heaven with his Second Coming. Logically, the Second Coming cannot have two phases if the Ascension only had one. This eliminates two phases of His Coming with a 7 year interval. Likewise, heaven must “receive” or contain Jesus “until the period of restoration of all things about which God spoke by the mouth of His holy prophets from ancient time”.[31] Most scholars[32] see this “restoration of all things” as the one-thousand year reign of Christ on earth (as prophesied in the Old Testament) which begins just after the Second Advent. If Christ is to remain in heaven until this coming rule of His according to thess verses (see also Hebrews 9:27,28), it would seem the next main prophetic event would be the Second Coming[33] rather than Him coming 7 years prior to get the church, bring them back to heaven, and then leaving heaven for earth again as the pre-tribulational rapture position indicates.[34]

    Pre-tribulational usage of Luke 17 can also be counter-balanced. In this eschatological scenario, Luke 17:37 explains what happens to the people that are “taken”: the eagles gather together at their [dead] bodies. Do they eat them? “Taken” may also have the idea of judgment and that Luke 17:22-37 is referring to the unmistakable visual nature of the Second Coming. Even the disciples are warned not to believe reports that Christ has come if they have not seen it “for just as the lightning, when it flashes out of one part of the sky, shines to the other part of the sky, so will the Son of Man be in His day.[35] Many take the fact that vultures hovering over a dead body is clearly visible from a great distance away to mean that the Second Coming will be clearly visible and will not be hidden. It seems that Luke 17 can be compared to Revelation 19, which reads that the fowls are invited to a feast—on the flesh of men, small and great, at the Lord’s coming.

    The Parable in Matthew 13 explains that the unsaved (tares) are destroyed first before the saved (wheat) are addressed. This parable[36] describes what the kingdom of heaven is like and it uses agricultural metaphor to explain that believers and unbelievers will remain together until the harvest. When is the harvest? Well, when Jesus explains the parable.[37] He says the harvest is the “end of the age” in verse 39. At that time he sends his angels[38] to destroy the tares while the wheat (believers) remain and shine forth as the sun in His Father’s kingdom. This seems to fit better with the Rapture and the Second Coming being one event rather than a time gap of 7 years.

    Zechariah 14, speaks of the “Day of the Lord” and that “in that Day His feet will stand on the Mount of Olives.” This exactly parallels the angel’s statement in Acts 1, “that as He left so shall He return.” Tying this with I Thessalonians 4:16-17, we see all the living and dead Christians are gathered to Jesus at that time. Going back to Zechariah 14:5 we read, “Then the LORD my God will come, and all the holy ones with him. ” This inexorably links the return of Jesus to the glorification and “rapture” of Christians to Him.

    In Revelation 2:25 31 Jesus says to the faithful at Thyatira, “Nevertheless what you have, hold fast until I come.” In other words, ‘hold onto the truth of the Christian faith and its obedience amidst the false teaching of Jezebel and her sins, until My coming again.’ Pre-trib commentators agree this could be talking about the Second Coming of Christ (John MacArthur,[39] Robert L. Thomas).[40] Would Jesus say hold on to the faith until I come again if they were not going to be there when he returned, but would have already been raptured? Expositor’s Bible Commentary also makes this assertion.[41]

    Be patient, therefore, brethren, until the coming of the Lord. Behold the farmer waits for the precious produce of the soil, being patient about it, until it gets the early and late rains. You too be patient; strengthen your hearts, for the coming of the Lord is at hand.[42]

    They are to be patient amidst persecution until when? Until the coming (parousia) of the Lord. Parousia is well known to mean “presence” and refers to His second coming many times in the New Testament.[43] Also notice that the farming analogy seems to indicate that the farmer is aware of the coming rains just as the believer is aware of coming end time events.[44] For example Jesus warned “when you see these things begin to take place [end time signs in the sun, moon, and stars / world chaos], straighten up and lift up your heads, because your redemption is drawing near.”[45] This manner of expectancy is objected to on the grounds that it destroys the idea of Christ’s rapture of the church being imminent, or able to occur at any moment. But imminent probably doesn’t mean ‘at any moment’ in the New Testament.[46] Many New Testament passages implicitly rule out an “any second” imminency (Matthew 24:45-51…25:5,19;Luke 19:11-27;John 21:18-19Acts 9:15…).[47] At the very least Apostles Peter and Paul could not have believed in this kind of imminency because Peter was told by Jesus what manner of death he was to die and that it would take place many years later. Jesus said, “Truly, truly, I say to you, when you were younger, you used to gird yourself, and walk wherever you wished; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands [be crucified], and someone else will gird you, and bring you where you do not wish to go.”[48] Could Peter think the Rapture was at any moment with this enduring prediction by Jesus?[49] Also, it was told of Paul that he would bear Christ’s name “before the Gentiles and kings and the sons of Israel” and that God would “show him how much he is to suffer for My name’s sake.”[50] Does an any moment Rapture fit with such a massive missionary plan revealed by God for Paul’s life which took decades to complete? Jesus encouraged the first disciples and all Christians, to look for certain events which would indicate His coming was “at the doors.” This coupled with other passages like 1 Thessalonians 5:2-6, seems to indicate moral watchfulness, waiting in expectancy,[51] and sobriety (“be sober”) and that the wrath of that day will overtake those in darkness (unbelievers) like a thief “but you, brethren, are not in darkness, that the day should overtake you like a thief.”[52][53] Thus a different concept of imminency emerges.

    Jesus, speaking chronologically in the Olivet Discourse regarding end time events,[54] goes from the escalation of troubling times beginning in the 1st century and the present age (highlighting the destruction of Jerusalem by Rome in A.D. 70) to the time of tribulation and then to His Second Coming without any mention of a prior removal of the church 7 or 3.5 years before it. One author sees Jesus as advocating a “delay” between the destruction of Jerusalem and His Second Advent.[55] On the contrary, he states that “immediately after the tribulation of those days…they [the world] shall see the son of Man coming…and He shall send His angels, and they shall gather His elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other.”[56] Therefore, Jesus seems to put the rapture just before his second coming or on his way to earth. The phrase “gathering together” describes the rapture in 2 Thessalonians 2:1 using the noun form of the same Greek word.[57]

    Paul says: “we who are alive and remain [on the earth] until the coming of the Lord, shall not precede those who have fallen asleep[died].”[58] Then he points out that the Lord’s coming with angels and the trumpet call will invite those already dead in Christ to rise from the dead before the ones on earth participate in the event. Then Paul states: “Then we who are alive and remain [on earth] shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and thus we shall always be with the Lord.”[59] Some commentators[60] note that because Paul used the plural “we” when referring to those who “are alive and remain[on earth]” indicates that Paul believed that he and all believers on earth might witness and be a part of the Second Coming of Christ from earth. This would indicate that he would be on earth just prior to the coming of the Lord and the Rapture. This is also the usage when he speaks of the same event saying: “We shall not all sleep [die], but we shall all be changed-in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.”[61] This passage adds the fact that believers will receive glorified bodies which is missing from the Thessalonian passage].”[62] If believers were raptured before the tribulation then why would Paul use “we” and consider himself with all Christians to possibly be those who would be “alive and remaining [on earth] until the coming of the Lord?” They wouldn’t be alive and remaining on the earth at His coming in a pre-tribulational scenario but would already be with Jesus in clouds along with the other believers who had died in Christ.

    The Church and the Tribulation

     

    Some who believed in Post-Tribulation Rapture

    Published September 22, 2011 | By JapanKen

     
    Optin Cat: Invalid Form ID